Beneath the Stares / Chapter 4: Kindness for Sale
Beneath the Stares

Beneath the Stares

Author: Kathleen Chen


Chapter 4: Kindness for Sale

← Prev

Savannah burst into tears.

Her sobs echoed around the classroom, dramatic and loud. Someone ran to get the nurse. I felt a cold pit open in my stomach—somehow, this would be blamed on me, too.

I stood there helpless, but Tyler freaked out.

He hurried over and grabbed Savannah’s hand. “You okay?”

Before I could apologize, he stood in front of Savannah again, shielding her, and yelled at me:

“Lila, are you done yet!”

His voice was sharp, slicing through the noise. I shrank back, my hands trembling. Everyone watched, waiting for me to snap.

I stared at him blankly, then took two steps back.

“I didn’t touch Savannah. And the scholarship was supposed to be mine.”

My voice was barely audible, but it was the truth. I could see the disbelief in his eyes, the way he refused to hear me.

Tyler’s face darkened.

He stood in front of Savannah, who was still crying, like some kind of knight, and said:

“What would you even do with it? Isn’t it just to treat your nasty disease?”

Wow—

The whole class erupted.

Laughter, whispers, the snap of someone’s gum. Heat rushed to my face. It felt like I was on stage, exposed, with nowhere to hide.

I tried to stop him, pleading softly, “Please, stop.”

“It’s just facts. You’ve been itching for months. You think cash is gonna fix that?”

“I’m begging you.” I grabbed his sleeve, but he jerked away.

He ignored how pale I’d gotten and just kept going.

“Savannah’s kind, and those kittens out back are about to have babies. This money’s for their rescue. You think your gross problem matters more than them?”

Next thing I knew,

The class, quiet for a beat, exploded into chaos.

Everyone’s eyes on me were full of scorn.

Their words were sharp and loud.

“Didn’t think Lila looked so proper, but she’s got some weird disease. No wonder I felt itchy after touching her.”

“People like her should just drop out—why do we have to deal with her?”

“She acts all innocent, but she’s so nasty behind the scenes.”

Tyler hadn’t expected them to take it that far.

He hesitated for a second, watching me sit back down, head bowed, trembling.

He coughed, looking uneasy.

“Lila, I didn’t mean it like that.”

Before he could finish, I nodded quietly.

“Fine, the scholarship’s hers.”

My voice was flat, beaten down. I pressed my hands into my lap, hoping no one could see them shake.

Last time, Savannah went through my backpack while I was in the bathroom.

She took a liking to the only birthday gift my mom ever bought me—a nice pen.

She wanted to take it right then.

I refused.

Later, when I got back from gym, I found out Tyler had tossed the pen straight into the school dumpster.

It was ruined.

After that, I didn’t dare say no to Savannah about anything.

She didn’t like my thick, long hair. After homework club, she chopped it into a jagged bob.

She didn’t like my skin being paler than hers.

So she sprinkled itching powder all over my desk.

I put up with it all.

But about my illness, I only told Tyler.

Now, everyone’s stares and snickers stabbed into me like pins.

I sat stiffly, clutching my shirt, not arguing anymore.

Seeing me fold so easily, Tyler walked over and patted my head.

“Lila, just be good. If you really need it, I…”

His voice was soft, almost like he was humoring a little kid. I stared straight ahead, refusing to meet his eyes.

Before he could finish, Savannah suddenly collapsed beside him.

Someone shouted, “The class queen fainted!”

“Ty, my stomach hurts.”

Tyler immediately panicked. He helped Savannah back to her seat.

He skipped physics to get her hot water from the hall.

He went to the vending machine for a heat pack.

Even during break, he ordered delivery for her favorite plush toy.

Savannah blushed and thanked him, always clutching his sleeve, refusing to let him go.

I sat not far away, quietly watching, my heart burning like it was full of fire ants.

All of this, I’d taught him.

But he’d never done any of it for me.

When I almost fainted from cramps during gym, Tyler hadn’t helped me once.

He just stood far away in the corner.

That day, he texted:

“You feeling better?”

“An eighteen-year-old guy like me can’t do this stuff, I’d get roasted.”

“When I’m twenty-eight and marry you, then I’ll have the right to.”

After that, I never begged him for help again.

I stopped watching that sweet scene across the room.

I counted the minutes until class ended, desperate to get to my part-time job.

This month, Mom and I were still short on rent.

As soon as the bell rang and I was about to leave, Tyler stopped me.

“Wait. You haven’t apologized to Savannah for today.”

I just thought he was being ridiculous.

“Let go of me!”

He grabbed me hard and shoved me. “I said, apologize!”

I hit the floor hard.

Pain shot through my lower body, and my jeans were instantly stained red.

A passing classmate screamed, covered their mouth in disgust, and jumped away.

“Ew, that’s so gross—even bleeding. What if she gets everyone sick!”

In a heartbeat, all my classmates glared at me.

I don’t know who started it.

Backpacks, pencil cases, sharp compasses—all rained down on me.

Tyler just held Savannah and watched coldly from the side.

“Lila, apologize to Savannah.”

“You scared her today, and now you’ve made yourself so gross.”

“Your disease—it’s not contagious, right?”

I took a shaky breath, wiping blood from my face, scratched by a compass.

I crouched down, hugging my head.

“Sorry,”

“Sorry.”

“It’s my fault for not appreciating kindness.”

Maybe my weakness made everyone lose interest.

The crowd scattered, looking awkward.

I gritted my teeth, stood up, and bolted from the room.

“Lila!”

Tyler chased after me.

I ran faster and faster.

The wetness at the corners of my eyes stung my wounds like salt.

When I got home,

Mom was sitting by the bed, holding that little tin box, counting money.

When she saw me come in, she stood up, worried.

“Lila, have you eaten?”

“I’ve eaten.”

I forced a smile.

But suddenly, a look of pain flashed across Mom’s face.

I quickly found an excuse to hide in my room.

Closing the door, I leaned against it, listening to her muffled sobs outside.

My eyes quietly turned red.

Last year, Mom wasn’t like this—a shell of herself.

Listening to her cry, I bit my lip until it bled.

It was all my fault.

Suddenly, a thunderstorm started outside the window.

Raindrops hammered the old window screen like bullets.

It was suffocating.

That night, it rained even harder than this.

Mom was worried about me, so she planned to pick me up after homework time.

The alley was too dark.

A drunk was hiding in the corner…

When I got home, Mom was hiding in the bathroom, washing for a long time.

Covered in bruises.

She told me she just fell.

After that, she lost her job.

People in the neighborhood all said she had a dirty disease.

I didn’t believe it,

Fought with those women all the time.

Until the day I got my period.

My jeans were dirty, but no one told me.

My embarrassing moment was caught by Savannah and spread in the class group chat.

Tyler even hid the pads I kept in my desk to make her laugh.

I could only rush home to change.

It was too dark inside, so I put on Mom’s underwear.

After that,

I got sick too.

But I didn’t dare tell her.

Afraid she’d break down.

I kept thinking, when the scholarship came, I could go to the clinic for medicine.

But now, the money was gone.

The sound of rain slowly faded.

The crying outside stopped too.

I lowered my head and quickly opened the door, not daring to look at her.

“Mom, I’m going to work.”

At the entrance of the new smoothie shop,

I ignored my empty stomach, wearing a heavy mascot head, handing out flyers on a nearly 100-degree day.

Sweat poured down, and my body started itching unbearably again.

I felt so uncomfortable I wanted to double over.

But the mascot head slipped off.

When I looked up, two familiar figures stood in front of me.

Tyler and Savannah.

They were hugging and kissing right in front of the store.

I froze in place.

Last time during homework hour, the whole school suddenly lost power.

In the dark, Tyler pulled me into the hallway.

That was the first time he kissed me.

Warm breath, the scent of mint, a shy kiss.

Tyler’s face was just inches from mine.

His eyelashes brushed my cheek, tickling.

“Lila, when we graduate, let’s be together.”

“And then never, ever separate, okay?”

I nodded, panicked, not wanting to let go of his hand.

I always thought he, like me, would keep his promise.

Turns out, it was just wishful thinking.

——

I hurriedly picked up the mascot head, but heard Savannah shriek.

“Why is Lila here!”

I wanted to run, but Savannah grabbed me.

She held Tyler’s arm, stood in front of me with red eyes, and pointed at me.

“Ty, doesn’t Lila have some gross disease? If she’s handing out flyers here, everyone will get infected.”

“I’m telling the manager.”

She turned and ran.

I panicked,

This was my last shot at making money. If I couldn’t pay rent, Mom and I would be out on the street.

“No!”

I grabbed her hand, but she screamed and shook me off!

The flyers blew away in a sudden gust.

Hearing the noise, the manager came out.

I froze, watching Tyler help Savannah explain everything, word by word.

Savannah giggled and nodded, glancing at me with a cold sneer.

“Don’t come again.”

The manager tossed two days’ pay—twenty bucks—on the ground.

Every way I had to make money was gone.

“Bitch.”

I couldn’t help but spit at Savannah.

She immediately covered her face and cried.

“Ty, you know, I was just being kind, hoping Lila would get better before coming to work.”

“I was thinking of everyone’s safety. Was I wrong?”

She sobbed, tears streaming down her face.

I looked in disbelief at Tyler’s angry face.

“Lila!”

He snatched the envelope with my pay.

He raised his hand and hurled it into the pond next to the shop.

“Are you so broke you can’t live? If you love money so much, go fish it out of the pond!”

“And apologize to Savannah! She’s being kind and thinking of you. Why don’t you appreciate it!”

I just wanted to jump in after it, but he held me back tight.

“Apologize!”

With a thud, I dropped to my knees.

“Sorry!”

“Sorry.”

“It’s my fault for not appreciating kindness.”

Tyler was stunned and let go of me.

Even though it was a blazing summer day, I felt cold all over.

The cicadas buzzed in the trees, the heat pressed down, but I shivered. I wiped my eyes and stood up, my dignity left somewhere on the sidewalk. I wondered if this was the moment I’d finally disappear for good.

This chapter is VIP-only. Activate membership to continue.
← Prev

You may also like

Buried Beneath Her Bed
Buried Beneath Her Bed
4.9
Derek Foster built a secret bed to hide beneath the woman he’s obsessed with, craving the intimacy she’ll never willingly give. But when her fiancé enters the picture, Derek’s obsession spirals into violence—and a gruesome, claustrophobic nightmare. Now, trapped with a rotting corpse and his sanity slipping, Derek realizes too late that love and madness are only a heartbeat apart.
Beneath My Bed, Her Ghost Waits
Beneath My Bed, Her Ghost Waits
4.9
Marcus, trapped in the shadows of his family’s cruelty and poverty, faces a nightmare when a grieving woman searching for her sons stumbles into their rural Appalachian home. As secrets unravel and violence spirals, Marcus must choose between survival and his last shred of humanity. But the cost of silence may haunt him forever.
Forbidden Steps
Forbidden Steps
5.0
Grace returns to her fractured family, only to find her forbidden love for Mason—her stepbrother—still burning beneath the surface. With gold-diggers circling and old wounds reopened, Grace must choose: sabotage her brother’s wedding for a shot at reclaiming her lost happiness, or finally break free from the past. But in this high-stakes game of love and legacy, nothing stays buried forever.
His Rough Hands, My Secret Tears
His Rough Hands, My Secret Tears
4.9
After losing her family in a shocking identity swap, Natalie is exiled to rural Ohio and forced to endure grueling labor and icy stares. When a mysterious string of live comments hints at a forbidden connection with her intimidating crew chief, she faces a choice: stay invisible, or risk everything for a chance at belonging—and maybe love. Will Natalie finally find a place to call home, or is she doomed to remain an outsider forever?
Haunted by the Midnight Maestro
Haunted by the Midnight Maestro
4.6
Derek came to Chicago chasing stardom, but found himself learning forbidden secrets from a phantom voice haunting the theater’s midnight shadows. As his talent grew, so did the chilling suspicion that the price of his gift was more than just sleepless nights—especially when his confession brought the city’s secret ghost-catchers to the stage. Now, with the truth threatening to destroy him, Derek must choose: expose the supernatural bargain or risk becoming the next legend whispered about in the dark.
Beneath the Office Ceiling
Beneath the Office Ceiling
4.7
When Lauren, a meticulous office worker, becomes convinced that something sinister is dripping from the ceiling, her life spirals into paranoia and fear. As her colleague tries to support her, both are drawn into a chilling mystery that threatens to unravel their sanity and their friendship. What lurks above could change everything they thought they knew about their safe, ordinary workplace.
He Claimed Me—Back in High School
He Claimed Me—Back in High School
4.9
Waking up in her old high school body, Savannah thought she’d seen it all—until Carter Reed, the school’s untamable bad boy, starts declaring she’s his wife in front of the whole school. Suddenly, her quiet do-over is hijacked by rumors, jealous rivals, and Carter’s relentless (and ridiculous) pursuit. As Carter battles Diego, the heartthrob with Ivy League dreams, Savannah’s world spirals into chaos—detentions, band-aids, luxury brands, and family dinners where Carter fits in far too well. But beneath Carter’s bravado lies a heartbreak he can’t hide and a desperate need to rewrite his own future. Is this a second chance at love, or just another high school disaster waiting to happen? When Carter finally drops his guard, will Savannah run—or realize he’s the only one she’s ever wanted?
No Sleep, No Surrender
No Sleep, No Surrender
4.8
Every dawn, Maple Heights shakes awake to the same ear-splitting chorus: one cantankerous old man, a Broadway wannabe, making sure no one gets a wink of sleep. When a battle-scarred insomniac moves in—lured by dirt-cheap rent and nothing left to lose—he finds himself at war with the neighborhood’s untouchable menace. But this isn’t just about lost sleep: the old man’s secrets run deeper, and his reign of terror has left scars on everyone around him. As petty games spiral into full-blown chaos, alliances form and the whole block watches, desperate for a hero—or at least a little peace. When revenge is the only thing keeping you awake, just how far will you go for one quiet night? Or will the noise finally break them both?
Night Stalker in Maple Heights
Night Stalker in Maple Heights
4.8
A father races against time when a sinister online threat creeps from his HOA Facebook group to his own front door. As twisted pranks turn deadly and paranoia spreads, he must protect his family from dangers lurking both online and in the halls of their new home. In a world where trust is scarce and every neighbor is a stranger, survival means questioning everything—and everyone.
The Senator’s Son Broke Her Smile
The Senator’s Son Broke Her Smile
4.8
When a senator’s twisted heir shatters a farm girl’s body and soul, Maple Heights turns a blind eye—except for one cop. Derek Lane is the only man ruthless enough to drag the town’s monsters into the light, even if it means taking on the Seven Stars Society and the Deacon dynasty. But as secrets bleed and power shields the guilty, can Derek bring justice to a girl whose only crime was honesty?
Saints Die First—But I Survive
Saints Die First—But I Survive
4.9
Everyone thinks I’m the gentle saint holding our last safe haven together—but the apocalypse has no place for saints. My mask of kindness is just that: a weapon for survival, and now a new girl with knowledge of our story wants to expose me as the villain she believes I am. When Lila, the transmigrator, arrives with future-sight and ruthless logic, she shatters my fragile community, taking my place at the center and casting doubt on my every act of mercy. But I’m not as fragile as I seem. As monsters close in and trust turns to suspicion, the lines between savior and monster blur, and even those I save begin to see what lurks beneath my smile. Will kindness be my undoing—or is the real villain the one who survives at any cost? When the new world demands monsters, how long can a saint keep her mask?
Stuck in His Skin, Fighting Their Rules
Stuck in His Skin, Fighting Their Rules
4.9
Waking up in the body of Evan Carter—the school’s straight-A legend—was supposed to be my ticket out of mediocrity. Instead, I found myself suffocating under his parents’ impossible expectations and their chilling brand of ‘love.’ Every smile hides a threat, every meal is a test, and every mistake earns bruises—sometimes on my body, always on my spirit. As I stumble through Evan’s glass-box life, I uncover secrets about Mason Carter, the boy now living in my skin—and the ugly truth about what it really means to be ‘perfect.’ When my desperate acts spiral into public chaos and humiliation, I realize escaping this nightmare might cost more than I ever imagined. Can I outwit the parents who control everything, reclaim my life, and help Mason before we both lose ourselves forever? Or is this body swap the cruelest lesson of all?