He Chose Her Over Our Baby / Chapter 3: Ghosts and Goodbyes
He Chose Her Over Our Baby

He Chose Her Over Our Baby

Author: Jonathan Lewis


Chapter 3: Ghosts and Goodbyes

I met Gavin through a hiking club one bright spring morning. The air was sharp with pine and new grass, and all I wanted was to lose myself on the trails, away from my spreadsheets and late-night emails.

Back then, my life was a cycle of 80-hour workweeks, climbing the tech ladder, ordering takeout at midnight, and counting down the days till Saturday’s hike. Nature was my only reset button.

Gavin joined the club my second year. He was just another face at first—a guy with a buzz cut and an REI backpack. But we kept finding ourselves at the front of the pack, always reaching the summit together, breathing hard, grinning at the sky.

He worked in finance; I worked in tech. He loved sports and hiking. So did I. We swapped stories about getting lost on the Appalachian Trail and eating too many s’mores by the campfire.

So when we hit our hundredth mountain together—sweaty, muddy, the air full of birdsong—he turned to me, no grand gesture, and said, "Natalie, let’s date."

No ring hidden in a cupcake, no skywriting—just that. And honestly, it was what I needed. My dad had chased my mom with wild declarations—setting off fireworks across half of Kansas City, getting arrested for disturbing the peace. But that didn’t stop him from being obsessed with having a son after marriage, making my mom choke down herbal supplements for years, until it finally cost her her life in childbirth.

So for me, romance and novelty were overrated. What I wanted was solid ground.

And Gavin was steady, like a good pair of boots. Never late for a date. Gifts were simple but never forgotten. He wouldn’t drive across town in a rainstorm without being asked, but whenever I called, he showed up. Quiet reliability—nothing flashy, but real.

In our third year together, we got married. No drama, no spectacle. Just a small church with our friends and a barbecue at my aunt’s afterward.

Life after marriage rolled on much like before. I cooked, he washed the dishes. I shopped for groceries, he hustled home early to make dinner on Fridays. We argued about laundry and bills but always ended up sharing ice cream on the couch by midnight.

Those easy, uneventful days lulled me into believing Gavin was the perfect partner. Until three years ago, when he took me to a college friend’s wedding out in Columbus.

At the bachelor party, Gavin’s buddy—already several beers in—clung to him, voice thick with tears and whiskey:

"Bro, you used to light up a room. Now you’re just... I dunno, man. If Jenna hadn’t gone overseas, maybe you wouldn’t be so closed off."

Gavin’s eyes darted to me across the table, panic flaring up for just a second. "Don’t listen to him, he’s drunk."

I just smiled, cool and unbothered, and said nothing. But on the drive home, with Ohio cornfields flashing by, I said softly, "Gavin, I have a lot of flaws, but I’m good at cutting off feelings quickly."

He stood in the hallway shadows when we got home, his face unreadable in the dark. After that, Jenna Young disappeared from our conversations, our phones, our lives.

Until now.

This chapter is VIP-only. Activate membership to continue.

You may also like

He Chose Her—So I Chose Me
He Chose Her—So I Chose Me
4.9
A car ride was all it took to shatter twenty years of sacrifice. When I, a devoted single mother, dared to sit beside my son, his girlfriend unleashed accusations that turned my world upside down—and my own child sided with her. I’d saved, planned, and dreamed for his future, only to be cast out and humiliated. As family lines blur and loyalty is tested, I’m forced to make a choice: cling to the son who betrayed me, or finally put myself first. Will my heartbreak become my freedom, or will the past pull me back in? When love turns to war, who gets the front seat in your life?
He Chose Her Over Me
He Chose Her Over Me
5.0
Natalie always believed her childhood love with Derek would last forever—until a wild outsider named Aubrey crashes into their lives, stealing his affection and her family's loyalty. Betrayed and replaced, Natalie must fight for her place in a small town where secrets, jealousy, and heartbreak simmer beneath the surface. She’s about to prove she’s nobody’s backup plan.
He Chose Her Over Me—Again
He Chose Her Over Me—Again
4.7
Emily always thought she’d be the Howell bride, until Chris shattered her trust—sacrificing her happiness for his mentor’s orphaned daughter. Humiliated, overlooked, and expected to give up everything for Lily, Emily finally refuses to play the gracious loser. When Chris announces his own engagement to Lily out of duty, Emily must decide: will she keep living in someone else’s shadow, or claim her own future—even if it means breaking every rule of Chicago high society?
He Cheated With My Best Friend While I Was Pregnant
He Cheated With My Best Friend While I Was Pregnant
4.7
Three years into my marriage to Chicago’s golden boy, I found out I was pregnant—then caught him in bed with my best friend. Humiliated, betrayed, and blamed by everyone, I faced an impossible choice: keep a baby for a man who never truly loved me, or finally break free. This time, I’m divorcing him and choosing myself, no matter what anyone says.
He Chose His Mistress Over Me
He Chose His Mistress Over Me
4.8
Rachel lost her family and clung to Ethan, the only man who ever showed her kindness—until the day he declared his secret lover would become his second wife. Humiliated and cast aside, Rachel is forced to plan their wedding, all while the whole town watches her heartbreak. But with the annulment papers signed, she realizes she doesn’t need anyone’s pity—least of all Ethan’s—and vows to reclaim her life, no matter how many rumors or rivals stand in her way.
He Cheated While She Carried His Baby
He Cheated While She Carried His Baby
4.6
Derek’s disgust for his pregnant wife grows with every pound she gains, pushing him into the arms of his high school sweetheart, Lillian. But when Lillian blocks him yet again, Derek is left with nothing but regret and the bitter truth that he’s the villain of his own story. Now, with a newborn at home and his marriage in shambles, Derek wonders if chasing lost love was worth destroying everything real.
He Chose My Twin Over Me
He Chose My Twin Over Me
4.9
Emma’s world shatters when her fiancé confesses he truly loves her fragile twin, Sophia. Betrayed by her family and haunted by secrets, Emma is forced to choose between two lives—or risk losing everything. Will she finally break free, or be erased by the lies she’s been forced to live?
I Chose Myself, They Chose Her
I Chose Myself, They Chose Her
4.9
Betrayal tastes bitter when it’s family. When Casey learns she’s the only one who can save her sister’s life, she tests her family’s love with a single devastating lie. But in her parents’ home, loyalty is a one-way street—and Casey is about to be cast out for good. Surrounded by indifference and favoritism, she faces a choice between saving herself or sacrificing everything for those who never chose her. As secrets unravel and accusations fly, Casey must decide: will she cling to the hope of belonging, or finally walk away to protect the new life growing inside her? When blood is just another weapon, can she survive the cut?
He Chose Her at the Altar
He Chose Her at the Altar
4.9
Natalie thought her marriage to small-town golden boy Derek would heal old wounds—but his heart is still haunted by another woman. When betrayal resurfaces at her own family’s doorstep, Natalie must decide: keep pretending for the sake of her daughter, or finally break free from a love that was never truly hers. Will she ever be more than his second choice, or is heartbreak her only inheritance?
He Chose My Rival Over Me
He Chose My Rival Over Me
4.8
Natalie Carson thought marrying Derek would finally make her whole, but a shocking twist gives her a second chance—and a glimpse at the betrayals lurking behind small-town smiles. Now, with only twelve days to reclaim her future and her family's legacy, she must defy the man she once loved and the rival who stole everything. Will Natalie break free, or is her fate already sealed?
He Chose Her After I Slapped Him
He Chose Her After I Slapped Him
4.6
After five years together, Rachel’s world shatters when her boyfriend Jason drifts away—and a single slap destroys his last shred of love for her. Now, as Jason turns to the perfect new woman and Rachel is branded the 'jealous supporting character,' she must watch her memories become someone else’s future. But when her heartbreak is broadcast like a reality show, will Rachel find the strength to reclaim her own story—or will she always be the girl he left behind?
He Used Me, Then Chose Her
He Used Me, Then Chose Her
5.0
Natalie thought sharing a bed with her childhood best friend meant they were more than just 'buddies.' But when Ethan chooses another woman for a blind date, Natalie is forced to confront the truth: she was never the one. As humiliation and heartbreak threaten to swallow her, Natalie must decide if she’ll finally put herself first—or keep playing the part everyone expects.