I Chose My Mistress Over My Dying Wife / Chapter 2: Fault Lines and Fragile Promises
I Chose My Mistress Over My Dying Wife

I Chose My Mistress Over My Dying Wife

Author: Aditya Joshi


Chapter 2: Fault Lines and Fragile Promises

“You’re still pregnant, stop doing these things.”

I gently took the spoon from Meera’s hand and helped her sit down. Meera smiled softly, her eyes warm and affectionate. She sat down heavily, one hand massaging her lower back, her smile slipping for just a second before she recovered.

She patted her pallu in place, as if adjusting her entire world with that one gesture. "Arrey, I’m fine, Rakesh," she said, trying to sound light, but her exhaustion was obvious. She’d always insisted on cooking for Aryan, as if good food could melt old resentments. I wondered, not for the first time, if our new life together was fair to any of us.

“Aryan is working hard in his second year of junior college, so I made him some soup.” She gripped my hand tightly, her eyes sparkling. “Aryan has finally stopped opposing us having a baby. Does that mean he won’t object to us getting married either?”

Her bangles jingled as she squeezed my hand, and I remembered how, in college, her laughter used to echo in the canteen. She looked at me hopefully, searching my face for reassurance. For a second, I wished I could give her all the certainty she wanted.

I held Meera’s hand in return, smiling and nodding. My heart was as excited as hers. After a year of trying to talk sense into my son, Aryan, he had finally stopped fiercely opposing me and Meera having a child. Every time I’d tentatively ask him at dinner if he wanted a younger sibling, Aryan would fling his steel thali onto the floor, rice and dal splattering across the marble, his voice hoarse with rage. Sometimes he’d even erupt on the spot, cursing Meera as a mistress and her unborn child as illegitimate.

I still remembered the clatter of the steel plate, the rice scattered on the marble floor, Meera’s quiet flinch as Aryan’s words pierced the room. Even the maid, Sumitra, had stopped in her tracks, her eyes darting between us, unsure whether to clean up or disappear. Every meal felt like walking on glass, but I couldn’t stop trying. In this house, even our silences screamed. The sticky heat of a Pune evening clung to our skin, the ceiling fan humming overhead, barely stirring the thick air.

Seeing him so unreasonable, I was deeply disappointed and even wanted to slap him—to let him know that I am the father, and he has no right to interfere in my affairs. But every time, Meera would swallow her grievances and gently stop me.

She’d hold my wrist, her grip cool and soft. She’d tuck a loose strand of hair behind her ear, refusing to meet my gaze, her dupatta twisted tight in her fist, whispering, “Rakesh, don’t.” She would try to smile at Aryan, and for a moment, the air would thicken with everything unsaid. My hand would tremble—one part anger, one part shame.

“Rakesh, don’t hit the child. I’m fine.”

“I can bear some grievances. Just don’t let it affect your relationship with your son.”

She would say this quietly, her eyes lowered, trying not to let her own pain show. In another house, perhaps, the new wife would have fought back. But here, Meera chose the harder road—acceptance, sacrifice, silence. Typical of Indian women, I thought, both proud and pained.

I gently stroked Meera’s swollen belly, my eyes full of apology. “But we already have a baby.”

The glow of the night lamp fell on her face, highlighting the tiny worry lines around her mouth. She pressed my palm to her stomach, as if willing me to share her hope and her fears. I wished I could promise her a family without cracks, but even I knew that wasn’t possible.

Meera shook her head, tears welling up. “As long as I can be with you, I’m willing, even if I have no status. I just feel sorry for our child…”

She tried to hide her tears, dabbing at her eyes with the edge of her dupatta. "What will people say? Logon ki zubaan toh chalti hi rahegi," she muttered, her voice catching. I felt a pang of guilt—her biggest worry was not herself, but what the world would think of her child.

So, I tried every possible way to reason with Aryan for nearly a year. Today, he finally relented. He just quietly put down his plate and spoon, nodded, and said, “Jo aapko theek lage, Papa,” before returning to his room without looking back.

The sound of his door clicking shut echoed louder than any fight we’d ever had. I stood in the kitchen doorway, hearing the distant strains of a Hindi film song playing from someone’s TV on the floor below. For the first time in months, I felt hope bloom—tiny, tentative, like the first shoots of green after a long drought.

Seeing that my son didn’t shout and make a scene as before, I finally breathed a sigh of relief. Now, all I wanted was to pull Meera close and celebrate together. To be honest, with her, I felt young again—that reckless feeling of risking everything for love, of being high-spirited and defying the world.

We laughed, quietly, so as not to disturb the children or the neighbours. I remembered the college days, when we’d dreamed of a life together in some far-off city—those dreams, packed away, suddenly seemed possible again. My hands found hers across the dining table, and for a minute, the world shrank to just the two of us.

Seeing me lost in thought, Meera gave me a playful glance. “Both children need to sleep. They have to get up early for school tomorrow.”

She gently reminded me, her voice low. "Kal subah ka alarm toh main hi lagaoongi, hai na?" She fussed with Riya’s water bottle, setting it beside Aryan’s. Her careful mothering, even in the smallest things, made the house feel whole for a second.

In their blue-and-white school uniforms, Riya’s plaits bouncing, Aryan’s shoulders hunched, they waited at the bus stop, pretending not to know each other. Aryan is my son with my late wife, while Riya is the child Meera brought with her. After I officially got together with Meera, I arranged for Riya to transfer to the same school as Aryan. Now both children are in their second year at a top school in Pune, and they’re about to become legal siblings, able to look after each other.

I tried to picture them together on the school bus—the awkward silences, the shy glances. In a city like Pune, gossip travels faster than the Pune-Mumbai Expressway, but children are resilient. I hoped that, with time, they’d form their own bond, separate from all the adult mistakes.

More importantly, thinking of this, I couldn’t help but touch Meera’s belly. Meera and I are about to have a child of our own. But amid the excitement, the image of my son’s silent back as he returned to his room flashed through my mind, leaving me uneasy. After all, Aryan has always been obsessed with his mother’s death and resents me and Meera. But the dead can’t come back to life, and the living should look ahead, right? I think my late wife wouldn’t want us father and son to remain trapped in grief.

The ticking of the old wall clock, inherited from my father, filled the room. For a second, I felt as if my late wife’s photograph, garlanded above the TV, was watching us—judging, maybe, or perhaps forgiving. I muttered a silent apology, not just to her, but to Aryan too.

Meera leaned on my shoulder and said sweetly, “So when will we have our wedding ceremony?”

She smiled with her whole face, her excitement bubbling over. "Proper shaadi, haan? With band-baaja and mithai, even if people gossip?"

I nestled with Meera, filled with love, completely unaware that the room facing the dining area had quietly opened a crack. It seemed as if a dark, unclear gaze was fixed on us… Of course, maybe it was just my imagination.

Somewhere, a chair creaked. I shrugged it off—must be the old furniture. Love makes us superstitious, I thought, even as I shivered.

This chapter is VIP-only. Activate membership to continue.

You may also like

He Chose Her, I Chose Myself
He Chose Her, I Chose Myself
4.6
After two years chasing Mumbai’s college heartthrob, Meera is humiliated when he publicly claims another girl—and leaves her to face cruel whispers and betrayal alone. But when he finally comes begging, Meera refuses to cry or cling, stunning everyone by choosing her dreams over his drama. On the day she leaves for a new life abroad, he realizes too late: the girl he took for granted is gone for good.
Divorced for His Mistress, Married by Command
Divorced for His Mistress, Married by Command
4.8
On her eighteenth birthday, Priya’s husband signs their divorce papers without a glance—too obsessed with chasing his runaway mistress to notice her heartbreak. Shunned by her own family and stripped of dignity, Priya is forced into a new marriage with a military heir, only to have her ex-husband return, demanding she serve his new bride. Torn between her wounded past and a cold, transactional future, Priya must decide: will she surrender again, or finally claim her own destiny?
I Gave My Wife’s Place to My Mistress
I Gave My Wife’s Place to My Mistress
4.8
For ten years, Priya endured childless nights and whispered shame, only to be cast aside when Rohit’s young mistress became pregnant. As Priya is forced out, Rohit basks in his new beginning—until a single message reveals a devastating secret: the child he fought for may not be his. In a world where family honour is everything, one betrayal threatens to shatter them all.
Caught Between Wife and Mistress
Caught Between Wife and Mistress
4.7
Kabir thought he had mastered the art of juggling two lives—devoted husband to Meera, secret lover to his fallen school crush, Ritu. But one rainy afternoon, Meera catches him at the clinic with Ritu, shattering years of trust and unspoken rules. Now, Kabir stands to lose everything: his perfect marriage, his pride, and the one woman who truly believed in him.
Traded for His Mistress: The Backup Bride
Traded for His Mistress: The Backup Bride
4.8
Meera was never Arjun’s first choice—just the orphan girl chosen to save the Mehra family’s honour. For three years, she cooked, prayed, and begged for a scrap of love, only to watch her husband parade his mistress through their home. On their wedding anniversary, Meera finally shatters, demanding a divorce and exposing the secret that will tear their family apart.
Switched at the Mandap: My Sister’s Husband
Switched at the Mandap: My Sister’s Husband
4.8
Forced to marry Rohan when my glamorous sister Priya ran away, I spent three years as the unwanted wife—living in her shadow, enduring his silent longing for her. When Priya returned, broken but beautiful, I finally demanded a divorce, shocking our family and the Mumbai elite. Now, as Rohan and Priya celebrate their wedding, I return with a new love by my side, determined to reclaim my dignity—even if the world calls me the villain who stole, and then lost, her sister’s husband.
Bought the MLA’s Son as My Slave
Bought the MLA’s Son as My Slave
4.8
I’m just a butcher’s daughter, but I dared to buy the missing MLA’s son at the market and chain him as my husband-slave. By day, he’s stubborn and silent; by night, he punishes me fiercely—his hatred burning deeper with every secret I uncover. When his real fiancée arrives to claim him, the entire city wants my humiliation, but if I let him go, will he destroy me—or does he crave my touch more than revenge?
Sold as the Second Wife
Sold as the Second Wife
4.7
Meera’s world shatters when her loving husband buys a deadly insect to make her barren—only for her to discover he’s a nobleman’s son, already married, and she’s nothing but a mistress in his gilded prison. Betrayed by the man she risked everything for, Meera must choose: submit to a life of shame as the barren second wife, or fight for her dignity in a house that will never accept her. In the shadows of Lucknow’s richest mansion, secrets, status, and shattered love collide—how far will she go to reclaim her fate?
I Betrayed My Wife for a Stranger
I Betrayed My Wife for a Stranger
4.8
A lonely househusband’s life unravels after a forbidden night with a mysterious woman on a trekking trip. Torn between his perfect, distant wife and the wild passion of his new lover, his secret threatens to explode when desire, guilt, and fate collide in Mumbai. But when his wife discovers the truth, he must finally choose between duty and the one woman who makes him feel alive.
I Hired a Goon to Ruin My Husband’s Mistress
I Hired a Goon to Ruin My Husband’s Mistress
4.8
When her billionaire husband threatens divorce for a younger, brilliant mistress, Devika refuses to lose the family, fortune, and respect she’s sacrificed everything for. Desperate, she hires a seductive street-smart fixer to seduce the other woman, igniting a scandal that could destroy them all. But as secrets unravel and her own children join the battle, Devika must decide how far a mother will go to keep her crown in a city where love is cheap but survival costs everything.
Divorced at the Reunion: My Wife Chose Her Ex
Divorced at the Reunion: My Wife Chose Her Ex
4.8
Rohan came to his wife's college reunion to play the dutiful husband, but one shocking night turned into public humiliation and betrayal. With his mother dying at home and Ananya basking in the spotlight of her first love's dramatic return, Rohan must choose: grovel for her love, or walk away forever. When the crowd demands his dignity as the price for his mother's life, will Ananya finally reveal her true heart—or is this marriage already dead?
Banished Goddess: Claimed by My Demon Ex
Banished Goddess: Claimed by My Demon Ex
4.9
Three hundred years ago, I betrayed my fox spirit lover to ascend as a heartless war goddess—only to be cast down to earth, forced to marry a mortal and regrow the very bonds I destroyed. Now, stripped of divinity and hunted by demons, my old flame returns—not as a lovesick companion, but as the vengeful Demon King, determined to break my cold resolve. Between seductive nights, bitter regrets, and rivals fighting for my bed, will I survive my exile... or lose myself to the man I once abandoned?