Mistaken in Bed: My Girlfriend’s Twin Trap / Chapter 5: Ritu’s Demands
Mistaken in Bed: My Girlfriend’s Twin Trap

Mistaken in Bed: My Girlfriend’s Twin Trap

Author: Aarav Reddy


Chapter 5: Ritu’s Demands

← Prev

The next morning, Ritu waited on a park bench, wearing a crop top, big eyes blinking, sipping chai from a paper cup. Old uncles walked laps, a stray dog dozed, the air fresh with the scent of dewy grass and distant samosas.

"Aren’t you cold?" I asked, eyeing her bare arms, shivering in my sweater. Typical Ritu—never cared about what anyone thought.

She handed me her half-finished chai. "Worried about me?" Her lips curled into a half-smile. Lipstick smudged the rim, and the masala chai was oddly comforting.

I pushed her hand away. "Don’t play these tricks." My patience was thin, her perfume—a mix of jasmine and something sharper—lingered in the air.

"Not drinking? Then I’ll leave and tell my sister you forced me." She stood up as if to go, her dupatta slipping from her lap. I noticed her hand trembled just slightly, and her voice was lower, almost a whisper.

My heart skipped a beat. I knew she meant it. Ritu never bluffed.

"Come back, I… I’ll drink." I gritted my teeth, took the cup, careful not to meet her eyes. I could smell the faint perfume and the warmth from her hand on the paper.

The tea was lukewarm, slightly too sweet. I tried not to think about how intimate the simple act felt.

"Tell me, why did you do all this?" My voice shook, anger and confusion simmering beneath the surface.

"Why else? Because I like you." She said it as if it was the most obvious thing in the world. I almost choked on the tea.

"Nonsense, we’ve only met a few times." I tried to sound stern, but even I wasn’t convinced.

"How many times did you meet my sister before you fell for her?" Her comeback was quick, sharp as ever. I was speechless.

She looked at me, eyebrow raised, challenging me to disagree. "What does liking someone have to do with how many times you meet?" Her eyes were bright, almost feverish, as if daring me to argue.

"I’m your saali." She grinned, eyes twinkling mischievously.

"We’re not married yet." I reminded her, but she just shrugged, unimpressed.

"Still, I’m your girlfriend’s sister." She stood up, puffing out her chest. "Ever since I was little, I’ve looked exactly like my sister. Face, body—everything’s the same. You saw, na, I’m not less than her in anything." Her voice cracked just a little, revealing insecurity beneath the bravado.

I stood up too, looking her in the eye. "I admit your sister is beautiful, and I like her a lot, but it’s definitely not just because of her looks." I spoke firmly, hoping she’d understand.

"Oh." She smiled, leaning in to whisper in my ear, "You saw, na, I’m not less than her in anything." The words made my face burn, heat creeping up my neck. I wanted to disappear.

"You really are crazy." I glared at her, unable to believe what I was hearing.

I tossed the chai away and started to leave. "Give up. Even if I broke up with your sister, I’d never be with you."

"If you leave, I’ll tell my mum you slept with my sister and then with me. You’ll never be able to marry my sister." Her eyes glinted with a strange determination. I felt trapped.

"Go ahead, I accept it. Let’s just break up then." I braced myself, ready to face the consequences.

"Then I’ll call the police and accuse you of rape." She said it, then paused—a beat of silence. Her hand trembled, a tear slipping down her cheek. Her voice cracked, "What else can I do, jiju?"

I stopped and glared at Ritu. "What exactly do you want?" My voice was low, trembling with anger and fear.

"Take responsibility for me." She said it so quietly, I almost didn’t hear. Her eyes searched mine, desperate and defiant all at once.

"But I slept with your sister too. Who am I supposed to be responsible for?" I ran my hands through my hair, feeling lost.

"Both." Her answer was immediate, almost flippant.

"The three of us together?" I laughed, the sound hollow. The idea was absurd, impossible.

"Not impossible." She shrugged, as if we were discussing what movie to watch, not our lives.

"Stop it. Your sister would kill me. You know she’d never agree."

She thought for a moment. "Then just be my boyfriend." Her voice was almost pleading now, the bravado slipping a little.

"Impossible." I said it firmly, arms crossed. "Find someone else, Ritu."

"Then… can you pretend to be my boyfriend…" She looked down, twisting the ends of her dupatta, her voice barely audible.

I sighed. "There are plenty of good men in the world. Why are you clinging to me?" I tried to keep my tone gentle, but I felt tired, defeated.

She suddenly fell silent, head lowered, tears rolling down like pearls. "Where are the good men? Why haven’t I met even one?"

"You will." I put a hand on her shoulder, meaning it. She sniffled, wiping her eyes on her sleeve.

Ritu grabbed my hand. "Jiju, be my boyfriend. For seven days. Just seven days. After that, I’ll personally explain everything to my sister and make sure you two get back together. My sister loves me the most—you have to trust me."

Her grip was tight, desperate. I hesitated, but something in her eyes made me pause.

"Really?" I studied her face, searching for any hint of deceit.

"Really, I swear. If I don’t do it after seven days, may I get hit by a bus when I go out…" She raised her hand, solemnly. I panicked, slapping my palm over her mouth.

I covered her mouth with my hand. "Enough, don’t swear. I promise you." Old superstitions ran too deep—I couldn’t let her say such things, not even in jest.

She grinned slyly, licked my palm, and I quickly pulled my hand away, shaking it in disgust, but unable to stop a small, helpless smile. What a mess, yaar. What a mess.

My phone buzzed—Neha’s name flashed on the screen. My heart stopped. What now?

This chapter is VIP-only. Activate membership to continue.
← Prev

You may also like

She Lied, I Spied: My Fiancée’s Secret Lover
She Lied, I Spied: My Fiancée’s Secret Lover
4.8
On the verge of marriage, I discovered my fiancée was leading a double life—sweet in my arms, but wild in another man's bed. Betrayed by the woman my family had already accepted, I became my own detective, uncovering every filthy secret she hid behind her innocent smile. Now, trapped between exposing her and protecting my shattered pride, I wonder: is revenge worth the heartbreak, or will I lose everything—including myself?
My Boyfriend Cheated—So I Kissed His Roommate
My Boyfriend Cheated—So I Kissed His Roommate
4.8
On the night I planned to surprise Arjun, I mistook his silent roommate Kabir for him in the darkness—only to later discover Arjun passionately betraying me with another woman. Humiliated and heartbroken, I turned to Kabir for comfort, and one impulsive kiss changed everything. Now, caught between revenge, forbidden desire, and the shame of my own mistake, I must decide: will I forgive, or burn it all down?
The Guide’s Trap: Her Revenge Trek
The Guide’s Trap: Her Revenge Trek
4.7
He thought he could lure city girls into surrender, but Ananya—his ex-partner’s betrayed fiancée—turns the tables, demanding to witness their darkest games. In a world where women are prey, she dares to become the hunter, risking shame and desire to reclaim her power. When the trap is set on Gulmohar Hill, who will fall—her, or the men who never saw her coming?
Reborn: The Bride Who Set Me on Fire
Reborn: The Bride Who Set Me on Fire
4.8
On my wedding night, my childhood sweetheart Ananya set our bridal suite ablaze, blaming me for the death of her forbidden lover. But when the flames took me, I woke up as a schoolboy again—right before she fell for the wrong boy and destroyed us all. This time, I know her secrets and her rage, but will changing fate only make the tragedy worse?
My Girlfriend Betrayed Me for Her Professor
My Girlfriend Betrayed Me for Her Professor
4.8
For five years, Rohan believed Ananya was his soulmate—until a secret online post and a string of messages revealed her affair with her married professor. As family pressures for marriage mount, Rohan’s world shatters, torn between exposing her lies and saving his pride. But in this web of betrayal and hidden desires, no one is as innocent as they seem—and revenge might be the only way out.
Sold to the Twins: Bride of Betrayal
Sold to the Twins: Bride of Betrayal
4.8
Ananya was traded to the Malhotra brothers as repayment for her father’s debts, only to become the plaything in a cruel game of mistaken identity and public humiliation. Pregnant by the wrong twin and tormented by her ex-best friend, she must choose: endure their mockery, or vanish before her secret is exposed at her own wedding. In Mumbai’s ruthless elite, survival means outwitting those who would destroy you—before they can turn your life into their next scandal.
Reborn as the Villain’s Scapegoat Bride
Reborn as the Villain’s Scapegoat Bride
4.9
On farewell night, I was framed and shamed as the campus villainess, forced into a loveless marriage with my childhood friend who only had eyes for the college queen. Betrayed, unloved, and killed in a tragic accident, I wake up back in my final year—armed with memories of every heartbreak and secret. This time, I’ll rewrite my fate, expose the real schemer, and rescue the bad boy who always called my name, even if it means tearing my own heart apart.
My Girlfriend Tried to Kill Me for Power
My Girlfriend Tried to Kill Me for Power
4.7
On graduation day, I finally awakened my power—to rewrite anyone’s ability with a single word. But the girl I loved, Meera, had a deadly secret: every time she kills a man who loves her, her strength doubles. Drugged and betrayed, I discovered her plan to murder me for her own rise—now, I hold the power to destroy or save the world, and she’s hunting me still.
My Brother’s Best Friend, My Secret Shame
My Brother’s Best Friend, My Secret Shame
4.7
I only wanted a safe ride home, but my brother sent Kabir—the campus heartthrob who once caught me at my most embarrassing moment. One midnight pickup, a million misunderstandings, and now I’ve seen him in nothing but his bedsheet! With my family watching and my heart racing, how can I ever face Kabir—or my brother—again?
Livestreamed Betrayal: My Proposal Became Her Scandal
Livestreamed Betrayal: My Proposal Became Her Scandal
4.9
I planned the perfect birthday proposal, only to livestream my girlfriend’s secret affair to a thousand friends, family, and colleagues. Trapped in my own car boot, I watched my dreams shatter as her lover—her married boss—offered me hush money, while our entire khandaan gossiped in real time. Now, my heartbreak is viral, and everyone wants to know: will I take revenge, or disappear in shame?
Trapped by Her Lies: The Security Guard's Curse
Trapped by Her Lies: The Security Guard's Curse
4.7
On Chaitra Navratri, Rohan risked his life to save a stranger, only to be branded a pervert and driven to ruin by her false accusations. Each time he dies, fate drags him back to the same cursed day—no matter how he tries to escape, her lies tighten like a noose. Now, with damning evidence appearing out of nowhere, Rohan must fight to prove his innocence before he loses everything again—his dignity, his family, and even his life.
Bought One Incubus, Got Two Husbands
Bought One Incubus, Got Two Husbands
4.7
Priya only wanted a gentle, obedient incubus to warm her cold Mumbai nights—but the delivery brought two: soft-spoken Aarav and wild, brooding Kabir. Now she’s caught between their devotion, their rivalry, and her own burning desires, trapped in a ‘buy one, get one free’ deal that’s too hot to handle. But as secrets simmer and emotions ignite, Priya must decide: is it a blessing or a curse to have two supernatural lovers fighting for her heart?