My Brother Stole My Second Chance / Chapter 2: Blood, Bruises, and Breaking Free
My Brother Stole My Second Chance

My Brother Stole My Second Chance

Author: Benjamin Turner


Chapter 2: Blood, Bruises, and Breaking Free

"Hey, man... here."

My brother lowered his voice, looking secretive and nervous, like he was hiding something shameful. He kept trying to slip his straw into my hand.

He hunched over the table, glancing at our parents out of the corner of his eye, acting like this was just some harmless prank between brothers. But I knew better. I could almost smell the desperation on him, like he was scared to be found out and even more scared to lose.

I sneered in disgust and jerked my hand back, breaking free from his little trick.

His fingers barely brushed mine, and I snatched my hand away, shooting him a look sharp enough to cut. For once, I wasn’t playing along with his games.

With my parents watching expectantly, I unfolded my slip and handed it to them.

The silence stretched, just the ceiling fan rattling above us. I slapped the slip onto the table and pushed it toward my mom, meeting her eyes dead-on.

"Mom, Dad, I drew the dropout straw. Since this is my fate, I accept it."

My parents took the slip and immediately frowned.

My mom’s lips pinched tight, her brow furrowed like she’d bitten into a lemon. My dad ran a hand through his thinning hair, looking away.

I narrowed my eyes, staring at them, searching their faces.

The air felt thick with disappointment and something else—something like regret, but not for me. I could see it in their eyes: this wasn’t how they wanted it to go.

Why, when their precious youngest son won the right to study, did they actually look reluctant?

It was almost funny. They spent years saying they just wanted what was best for us, but now that their golden boy had his shot, they acted like it was a disaster.

"Danny, your grades aren’t as good as your brother’s. You sure you wanna keep this chance for yourself?" my mom suddenly asked, her tone probing but her eyes betraying a flicker of urgency.

Her voice was all gentle, but I could hear the panic just below the surface. She was hoping I’d just hand it back, make things easy for her.

I looked at my mom in disbelief, my heart turning cold.

I remembered every time she’d dismissed me, every time she’d sided with my brother. I could feel the chill spreading through my chest as the truth settled in. This was never about fairness.

In my previous life, my brother had pushed to swap straws with me. My parents saw it, but let it happen in silence.

They just watched, letting him bend the rules, and afterward pretended they’d done nothing wrong. I was left holding the guilt, like a hand-me-down coat that never fit.

Afterwards, I was morally blackmailed by the whole family, drained in every possible way, and they all acted like it was only right.

Every phone call, every family dinner—always the same script: “He’s your brother. Don’t you want him to do well?” I used to swallow it all, thinking I owed them something.

Now that I choose to drop out, they try to persuade my brother to give up instead.

It was a slap in the face, seeing how quickly they twisted things to keep my brother on top. Suddenly my sacrifice wasn’t good enough.

So from the start, was their plan always to send me to college—just so they could leech off me later?

It all clicked together. College was never for me—it was just an investment in someone to support my brother.

I almost wanted to laugh.

The absurdity of it all made my lips twitch. If I didn’t laugh, I’d scream.

Laugh at myself—how could I have missed something so obvious?

I was always the dutiful son, so desperate for a scrap of approval, I ignored what was right in front of me.

Ever since I was old enough to understand, I knew I was different from my brother.

The signs were always there. Different birthday cakes. Different rules. Even the way they looked at us—my brother could do no wrong, and I could do no right.

Every Christmas, my brother got a Christmas gift, while I could only watch him dance around with joy.

I remember sitting on the couch, hands tucked under my legs to keep from reaching for his presents, watching him rip into wrapping paper while my parents beamed at him. I learned early how to make myself small.

I begged my parents, just wanting a toy truck I’d wanted for ages.

I spent weeks circling it in the Sears catalog, dreaming of lining it up with the rest of my brother’s toys. It felt like the only thing in the world I wanted.

But their reply was always, "You’re grown up now, you need to be mature."

Their words always landed like a door slamming shut. "It’s time you learned to go without," my dad would say, as if I was already supposed to be the man of the house.

But I was still a kid back then, and I stubbornly asked for that toy truck again the next year.

I’d press my case, eyes wide, trying to hold back tears, hoping they’d see me for once. But nothing changed.

I even pointed at my brother, asking why he got one every year and I never did.

It wasn’t fair, and I finally said so. But instead of sympathy, all I got was anger.

In the end, my dad glared and slapped me, scolding me for being selfish and not knowing how to save money for the family.

His hand was heavy, his words even heavier. “We’re not made of money,” he barked, as if my needs were a threat to our whole existence.

My mom crossed her arms and snapped, "Don’t you know you’re the older brother?"

That line stuck with me, echoing in my head every time I saw my brother get something I wanted. Being the oldest meant you got the short end, every time.

After that, I didn’t dare ask again. I didn’t dare fight my brother for anything.

One hard lesson was enough. I learned to bite my tongue, to let things slide, to be invisible when it counted.

That slap made my face swell up, and my classmates laughed at me at school for a long time.

The bruise bloomed purple on my cheek. Kids in my class pointed and giggled, whispering about how my parents must’ve really hated me. I wore it like a brand.

I swallowed all the unfairness of my parents’ favoritism, learning to hide my needs—because I knew it was useless to voice them.

It was easier to go without than to ask and be refused. I started shrinking into myself, dreaming about escape instead of toys.

...

"My brother’s grades are good, I’m willing to give him the chance," my brother said, putting on a righteous face. His carefully rehearsed expression was so fake it made me sick.

He puffed out his chest, acting like a hero, but I saw the calculation in his eyes. It was all an act for our parents, the same routine we’d played for years.

From childhood until now, this was the first time he didn’t fight me for something, the first time he acted like he was giving me something precious.

Even his voice shook with false sincerity. He waited for our parents’ praise, but their silence stretched, awkward and cold.

Little did I know, behind this so-called kindness was actually a push into a bottomless pit.

It was never a gift, just a way to tie me down, to justify their demands for the rest of my life.

He knew his grades were hopeless, that he’d never make it by studying, so he wanted to rely on our parents’ favoritism and make me responsible for supporting him.

I could almost hear the gears turning in his head, planning out years of handouts and guilt trips.

And my dear parents? Clearly, they thought the same way.

Their expressions said it all: this was the plan all along.

If you’ve always favored one child, why would you ever change?

Favoritism is a habit, and habits die hard—especially when they’re easy.

The spoiled one stays spoiled.

No matter how old we got, the rules never changed.

How could I have been so stupid in my previous life?

I clenched my jaw, hating how much I’d let them walk all over me.

So this time, I patted my brother’s shoulder, sounding regretful but really mocking him.

I made sure my voice dripped with fake sympathy. “No need. Fate can’t be changed. I accept it—you do your best.”

He looked stunned, mouth opening and closing like a fish, and for once, he had nothing to say.

You may also like

My Sister Stole My Life, But I Stole Her Husband
My Sister Stole My Life, But I Stole Her Husband
4.9
Betrayed and murdered by my jealous sister, I wake up back at the day of our fateful marriage choices. This time, I claim the powerful Army major she stole from me—while she’s left to rot in the bed of the Foster brothers. But as old secrets and new passions ignite, I realize my sister may have been reborn too... and she’ll stop at nothing to ruin my second chance.
Second Chance: The Stray Who Saved a Life
Second Chance: The Stray Who Saved a Life
4.9
A stray dog with a heroic heart battles betrayal and heartbreak when his own brother steals his chance at a loving home. Given a miraculous second chance, he navigates the icy halls of wealth, the sting of prejudice, and the fierce competition for belonging. In the end, he learns that true family is earned through loyalty, courage, and the quiet triumphs of everyday kindness.
She Stole My Life—Now I Want Revenge
She Stole My Life—Now I Want Revenge
4.9
Betrayal doesn’t end with death—it starts all over when you’re given a second chance. Mariah Sinclair lost everything: her team, her future, and her place in her own family, all thanks to a single, misunderstood moment and a sister who wore innocence like armor. But when fate rewinds the clock, Mariah returns to the day it all went wrong—with a heart full of vengeance, a locket that holds ancient secrets, and the ruthless will to survive. In a world where every teammate could be a traitor and every kindness is a weapon, how far will she go to reclaim what was stolen? When forgiveness is a luxury and trust is poison, can Mariah outwit the sister who ruined her, or will history repeat itself—bloodier than before?
Heir to My Brother’s Betrayal
Heir to My Brother’s Betrayal
4.9
Ryan sacrificed everything to save his family from ruin—only to be betrayed by the people he loved most. When he’s given a second chance on the day of his brother’s funeral, he vows to turn the tables and expose every dark secret. But revenge comes with a price, and one wrong move could cost him the only ally he has left.
Rejected Twice by My Real Family
Rejected Twice by My Real Family
4.7
After my birth family finds me, the girl who stole my life walks into the sea—and everyone blames me. Beaten, shunned, and framed by my own blood, I’m cast out and forced to choose between begging for love or building my own future. But when fate rewinds and gives me a second chance, I pick the one person who truly wants me—my outcast Grandpa—and vow never to crawl for their affection again.
No More Begging: Breaking Free
No More Begging: Breaking Free
4.8
Evan’s world shatters when his fiancée betrays him with his own brother, forcing him to confront the painful truth about loyalty, love, and self-worth. As he struggles to reclaim his life and dignity amidst family manipulation and heartbreak, a quiet assistant offers him a new perspective and hope for healing. With everything on the line, Evan must decide what he’s truly willing to fight for—and what he’s finally ready to let go.
Stolen Sons: Sold After My Mother’s Murder
Stolen Sons: Sold After My Mother’s Murder
4.8
Caleb watched his mother die and was dragged into a nightmare, ripped from home with his little brother and sold to strangers who erased their names. Eighteen years later, he returns to the town that betrayed him, haunted by the memory of the day his family was shattered and the brother he lost in the darkness. Some scars never fade—and Caleb will risk everything to uncover the truth, no matter who must pay.
Reborn as the Villain’s Scapegoat Sister
Reborn as the Villain’s Scapegoat Sister
4.6
After dying young, I woke up inside a novel as the infamous sister doomed to bully my autistic brother—and die hated by all. The whole family expects me to fight for love and attention, but I just want to survive without becoming the villain again. But when my brother reaches out with silent kindness, and the world keeps twisting my every move, can I rewrite my ending—or am I trapped in someone else’s tragedy?
Blinded by Him, Saved by Another
Blinded by Him, Saved by Another
4.9
He was supposed to be my forever—until he walked in with someone new on my birthday. Blinded by the accident that saved his life, I thought Mason would always be my anchor. But tonight, he shattered our unbreakable promise in front of everyone, leaving me exposed, humiliated, and forced to let go of the only love I’ve ever known. Just as my world collapses, Carter Hayes—the boy next door turned protector—returns, holding out hope, secrets, and maybe something more. When a chance at sight—and a second chance at love—appears, will I risk my heart and trust again, or is some darkness too deep to escape? When loyalty becomes betrayal, who will help me see the truth?
I Was Hired to Be My Brother
I Was Hired to Be My Brother
4.8
For half a million dollars, Tyler gave up his name, his face, and two years of his life—pretending to be his brother to care for Lillian, the blind heiress. Now, years later, she’s a ruthless CEO engaged to the wrong man, and Tyler is just a nobody in her empire, forced to watch her love his brother with memories that should have been his. When scandal threatens to destroy him, Lillian must choose: protect the man she thinks betrayed her, or finally uncover the truth about who really saved her in the dark.
My Stepchild Forced Me Out
My Stepchild Forced Me Out
4.9
After years of sacrifice, Mike is tossed aside by the family he built—until a miraculous second chance sends him back in time. Determined not to repeat his mistakes, he faces old temptations and new love, risking everything to reclaim his dignity and find real happiness. But when his past comes clawing back, will Mike choose loyalty or finally put himself first?
My Enemy’s Brother Stole My Heart
My Enemy’s Brother Stole My Heart
5.0
Emma survived a brutal group home and devoted her life to caring for the silent, troubled Nathan Miller—only to be betrayed and discarded when he finally speaks. As love and resentment tangle, Emma faces lies, humiliation, and a choice that could break her heart forever. Will she risk everything for the boy who destroyed her trust, or walk away for good?