She Blocked Me After Saying Yes / Chapter 2: Confessions and Rejections
She Blocked Me After Saying Yes

She Blocked Me After Saying Yes

Author: Anaya Reddy


Chapter 2: Confessions and Rejections

I was late to the farewell party because I had some errands to run for my mum.

Maa had sent me to buy sabzi on the way, and I’d spent too long bargaining with the bhajiwala. By the time I reached the party, sweat already trickled down my back. My shirt was crumpled, and I could still smell the faint trace of coriander on my hands.

When I arrived, I just happened to witness the school heartthrob, Arjun, confessing to Ananya.

The crowd had parted for him like in some filmi scene. Arjun was standing there with a bunch of marigolds—the marigold bouquet looked like it belonged at a temple, not a love confession, but somehow it suited him. His hair gelled, shirt untucked, face shining with confidence and nerves.

He stood there with a bouquet, looking both confident and shy. “Ananya, I’m not great at this, but I don’t want to have any regrets.

“I like you. Will you be my girlfriend?”

His voice trembled slightly, but he stood tall, the kind of moment where the entire batch collectively held their breath.

Our classmates started shouting and cheering them on.

The boys from the cricket team started whistling. “Oye hoye!” someone shouted. Girls were already giggling and whispering, phones out to capture the moment. Everyone wanted a love story for the school WhatsApp group archives.

“Say yes, say yes!”

“Arrey, shaadi card bhej dena, haan!” and “Bhabhi bolo, bhabhi!”

The chants grew louder, some clapping, some teasing. I joined in, a little too enthusiastically, trying to hide the pinch in my chest.

My heart tightened, but I forced myself to join in the chorus. “Say yes, say yes!”

Even my own voice sounded strained to my ears, but no one noticed in the din. Everyone’s eyes were on Ananya.

Ananya suddenly glanced at me, her expression clouded.

For a split second, her gaze found mine. My stomach flipped—did she see right through me?

It was just a flash, but our eyes met—and for a moment, her usual easy smile was gone. I wondered if I’d imagined it.

In the end, she turned him down.

The party noise deflated like a punctured football. Some girls gasped, some boys looked at each other in confusion.

Everyone let out a collective sigh of disappointment.

There were a few awwws and some awkward giggles. Someone muttered, “Ye kya ho gaya?”

Arjun paused, then forced a smile. “It’s okay, let’s just be friends then.”

He gave a lopsided grin, trying to save face, and ruffled his hair, almost like in the Hero No. 1 movies dads watch on Sundays.

He shrugged it off, calling out, “Come on, don’t let it spoil the mood. Eat, drink, have fun!”

He reached for a samosa, stuffing his mouth, and called for the DJ to increase the volume. “Aaj party toh banti hai!” he declared, forcing a laugh.

As if he hadn’t just been rejected in front of everyone.

I couldn’t help but admire his guts and composure.

Arjun managed to get everyone’s spirits up again, even making a self-deprecating joke about his broken heart. I thought, Arrey, this guy really has guts.

You may also like

Rejected Nine Times, Now He Wants Me
Rejected Nine Times, Now He Wants Me
4.8
After Arjun coldly rejects Ananya’s ninth confession, she finally gives up—only for him to come begging at her gate, haunted by the success she once gifted him. But this time, Ananya refuses to be the silent patron of his dreams or the joke of her mohalla. When her loyal childhood friend is doomed to die young, and Arjun’s new ‘secretary’ is waiting in the wings, Ananya must choose: will she chase love, or finally let them all see her walk away?
He Chose Her, I Chose Myself
He Chose Her, I Chose Myself
4.6
After two years chasing Mumbai’s college heartthrob, Meera is humiliated when he publicly claims another girl—and leaves her to face cruel whispers and betrayal alone. But when he finally comes begging, Meera refuses to cry or cling, stunning everyone by choosing her dreams over his drama. On the day she leaves for a new life abroad, he realizes too late: the girl he took for granted is gone for good.
Livestreamed Betrayal: My Proposal Became Her Scandal
Livestreamed Betrayal: My Proposal Became Her Scandal
4.9
I planned the perfect birthday proposal, only to livestream my girlfriend’s secret affair to a thousand friends, family, and colleagues. Trapped in my own car boot, I watched my dreams shatter as her lover—her married boss—offered me hush money, while our entire khandaan gossiped in real time. Now, my heartbreak is viral, and everyone wants to know: will I take revenge, or disappear in shame?
My Online Boyfriend Was India’s Gaming God
My Online Boyfriend Was India’s Gaming God
4.8
Kuhu thought her online romance was all fun and games—until her 'fake' pro player boyfriend crushed her in a public match, exposing both their secrets before the whole Indian server. Betrayed, blocked, and heartbroken, she tries to move on—until a viral esports showdown reveals his true superstar identity, and her own family’s tangled ties to his world. Can she reclaim her pride and love, or will their double life end in game over?
My Tutor Became My Cold Senior
My Tutor Became My Cold Senior
4.7
Rohan lied to his online tutor about failing St. Stephen's, then blocked her and vanished—only to find her, colder than ever, as his postgraduate senior at IIT Delhi. Now, trapped under her icy gaze and impossible expectations, he must face the girl who once saved his dreams, even as old secrets and regrets threaten to destroy them both. What will happen when she discovers the truth he’s hidden all along?
She Walks Among Us: The Humanoid Secret
She Walks Among Us: The Humanoid Secret
4.8
When Arjun welcomes a stranger to his ancient cave, his instincts scream—kuch toh gadbad hai. No one can spot the flaw, but fear spreads like wildfire, tearing the tribe apart. In modern-day Pune, Rohan’s search for the truth uncovers a chilling secret: the enemy can wear any face, even your own.
She Sold Her Nights, I Risked My Life
She Sold Her Nights, I Risked My Life
4.7
He was a shy college graduate; she was '25', the club girl whose world ran on quick tricks and heartbreak. When her mother's locket is stolen, he faces Pune’s deadliest gangster, risking blood and bone for a woman he barely knows. In a city of secrets and shame, will one desperate act buy him her love—or cost him everything?
She Swapped My Future for Her Own
She Swapped My Future for Her Own
4.7
Ananya sacrificed everything to become the district topper, but in Mumbai’s cutthroat school, even mehnat isn’t safe. When her so-called best friend Priya uses the secret 'swap system' to steal Ananya’s Olympiad victory, her dreams—and her pride—are shattered in front of the whole class. In a world where one click can destroy a lifetime’s effort, will Ananya reclaim her destiny, or will betrayal win again?
She Stole My Heart—and My Secret Gold
She Stole My Heart—and My Secret Gold
4.7
Kabir thought his Diwali luck had finally turned when the stunning Priya entered his life—until a drunken confession about hidden gold changed everything. Now, his best friend has vanished, Priya’s questions haunt him, and the police are at his door after a mysterious break-in. In a city bursting with lights and secrets, Kabir must face the chilling truth: the real danger is closer than he ever imagined.
She Lied, I Spied: My Fiancée’s Secret Lover
She Lied, I Spied: My Fiancée’s Secret Lover
4.8
On the verge of marriage, I discovered my fiancée was leading a double life—sweet in my arms, but wild in another man's bed. Betrayed by the woman my family had already accepted, I became my own detective, uncovering every filthy secret she hid behind her innocent smile. Now, trapped between exposing her and protecting my shattered pride, I wonder: is revenge worth the heartbreak, or will I lose everything—including myself?
She Pretended to Be My Nani
She Pretended to Be My Nani
4.8
When Rohan’s beloved Nani suddenly grows cold on WhatsApp, he pours his heart out to her—never suspecting the truth. The girl who secretly despises him, Ananya, is the one behind the loving stickers, cash transfers, and every 'accha baccha.' When the shocking truth comes out, will Rohan forgive the ultimate betrayal, or fall for the girl who knows him better than anyone?
She Stole My Flat, But Not My Fate
She Stole My Flat, But Not My Fate
4.7
After sacrificing everything to buy a dream home for Priya, Arjun is ruthlessly dumped the moment the keys are handed over—his love traded for a flat in her name. Humiliated by her family and left with nothing but debt, Arjun uncovers their betrayal and vows revenge, armed with secret recordings and ironclad evidence. In the city that never sleeps, will he reclaim his life—or will Priya's betrayal cost him everything?