She Chose My Rival Over Me / Chapter 8: Rumours and Toads
She Chose My Rival Over Me

She Chose My Rival Over Me

Author: Aditya Joshi


Chapter 8: Rumours and Toads

Soon, our story spread. I was filled with joy, thinking we’d receive blessings, but unexpectedly, we became the target of classmates’ malice.

Whispers turned to rumours, and soon, even the canteen staff had an opinion about us. My stomach dropped every time someone stared too long.

It happened after PT period, when we went to the canteen together.

Sweaty from running laps, we bought cold Limca and two samosas. I didn't care about anything except being with her.

I quietly told her, "Yaar, just now while playing cricket, something happened…"

I leaned closer, lowering my voice so no one else would hear.

She looked puzzled.

Her nose crinkled in confusion, hair sticking to her forehead. 'Kya hua?' she asked.

"What happened?"

I scratched my head and blurted out:

I tried to laugh it off, but inside, I was mortified. 'I hope no one else saw,' I whispered.

"I ripped my pants."

She gasped, then covered her mouth to stop from laughing out loud.

She was stunned for a moment, then burst out laughing.

Her laughter was infectious. Soon, I was laughing too, my embarrassment forgotten for a second.

I told her to stop, saying, 'Let’s eat first, I don’t want you to go hungry. I’ll find a seat, you get the food today.'

I gestured to the table by the window, trying to hide my torn trousers. She rolled her eyes and headed to the counter.

As always, she agreed cheerfully.

She grinned, 'Aree, tumhare pants phat gaye? Koi nahi, main le aati hoon samosa. Tum chup-chaap baitho.' She waved at the canteen uncle, placing the order with her usual smile. The sunlight caught in her hair, and I felt lucky just to know her.

But such a small thing—

One silly incident, but in our school, nothing stayed private for long.

Spread through the class, everyone knew.

By lunchtime, my ripped-pants story was the hottest gossip. Even the juniors smirked as I walked past.

'He’s not a real man, making a girl stand in the queue for food while he just sits and waits…'

The taunts stung, echoing in the corridors. 'Bada aaya hero banne!' someone shouted from the back.

'Did you hear? That guy in our class is such a jerk, always bullying Ananya, making her copy his homework and wash his tiffin dabba…'

They spun wild stories, exaggerating every small thing I did.

'Let me tell you, I heard that guy grew up in a single-parent family, has a weird temper…'

Whispers about my family floated through the air, sticking to me like burrs.

'I looked into it, his dad was a drunkard, abandoned the family, started a new one somewhere else…'

It hurt more than I expected—hearing my family's name dragged through the mud. Even Ananya's eyes clouded with worry.

'I also heard, back in middle school, he tried to get with a girl, tried to do something, the girl refused, so he slapped her, then transferred to our school…'

That last rumour spread like wildfire. Soon, even the teachers looked at me differently, suspicion in their eyes.

Even the chaiwala outside the school gate had an opinion—'Arrey, us ladke ka baap toh kab ka bhaag gaya tha, abhi yeh bhi kuch ulta seedha karega.'

Rumours of all kinds, each more twisted than the last, spread far and wide.

I tried to ignore it, but every snide comment felt like a slap. No one bothered to ask me the truth.

Naturally, I became everyone’s target.

Friends grew distant, girls avoided me, even the PT sir seemed to scowl at me more than usual.

I still remember, once while walking with Ananya on the school path, we ran into a few classmates.

They blocked our way, arms folded, smirks on their faces. I tried to keep my head up, but my palms were sweaty.

They didn’t bother hiding their contempt, saying with a sneer, 'Ananya, with your grace, how did you end up with such a toad, huh?'

That word—'toad'—echoed in my ears long after they left. I bit my lip to stop from crying.

Their words echoed in my head—'toad,' they called me. Even the stray dogs in the lane seemed to look at me with pity that day.

Even now, years later, that line still stings me.

Sometimes, when I look in the mirror, I still hear their voices, feel the shame creeping back.

Many teachers believed the rumours and held a grudge against me.

The maths teacher stopped calling on me in class. The history sir looked through me as if I was invisible. Even the librarian stopped smiling at me.

My pride made me unwilling to defend myself.

I refused to explain, even when Ananya pleaded with me. I thought if I just waited, the rumours would fade.

From then on, I withdrew from people, like smoke drifting into the clouds.

I’d wander to the paan shop, buy a single Melody toffee, and sit on the broken swing, watching the kites tangle in the power lines.

I spent more time on the terrace, watching kites fight against the breeze, letting the sky swallow me whole.

That was when Kabir made his move, openly bringing Ananya breakfast, escorting her back to the hostel, without the slightest hesitation.

He flaunted his intentions, making sure everyone noticed. Sometimes, he'd even wink at me as he walked past with her.

He boldly tried to take her away.

He'd crack jokes, offer to help with assignments, carry her books. Teachers and classmates cheered him on, as if it was all just good fun.

Ananya wasn’t good at turning down kindness.

She'd thank him politely, but never outright refuse his offers. I couldn't blame her—she was too gentle to hurt anyone.

His pursuit grew more intense, and he gained the support of teachers and classmates alike.

Soon, he was sitting with her in the library, walking her to her rickshaw, even helping her set up project charts.

Just like that, he naturally became the one always by her side.

My stomach churned, remembering all the times he’d corrected my English in front of the whole class. Now he’d be correcting Ananya’s too. I watched helplessly as my place in her life shrank with every passing day.

This chapter is VIP-only. Activate membership to continue.

You may also like

He Chose Her, I Chose Myself
He Chose Her, I Chose Myself
4.6
After two years chasing Mumbai’s college heartthrob, Meera is humiliated when he publicly claims another girl—and leaves her to face cruel whispers and betrayal alone. But when he finally comes begging, Meera refuses to cry or cling, stunning everyone by choosing her dreams over his drama. On the day she leaves for a new life abroad, he realizes too late: the girl he took for granted is gone for good.
Rejected the Rich Boy, Chose the Labourer
Rejected the Rich Boy, Chose the Labourer
4.9
Everyone expected me to say yes to the college’s golden boy, but I shocked them all by running into the arms of Rohan—the poor labourer with cement-stained hands and a heart that still aches from my betrayal. Now, with the real heroine Priya in the picture and my ex plotting revenge, I must fight for a love I once threw away. But in this city of secrets, can a girl like me ever rewrite her fate, or am I doomed to always be the second lead?
My Sister Stole My Fiancé on Diwali
My Sister Stole My Fiancé on Diwali
4.8
On the night of Diwali, my younger sister destroyed our family’s honour—and my fiancé sacrificed everything to save her name, shattering my own engagement and reputation. As whispers poison my home and blame falls on me, I uncover a shocking secret: Priya is no longer herself, and everyone I love has chosen her over me. Betrayed and cast aside, I vow to fight for my own destiny—even if it means making a dangerous pact with the enemy prince who once ruined me.
Rejected by My Childhood Fiancé
Rejected by My Childhood Fiancé
4.7
Everyone expected Ananya to choose Kabir—the golden boy she’d loved since childhood. But when she finally confesses, she discovers his heart belongs to someone else, and her own family’s pride becomes her prison. Torn between a loyal army officer and the boy who never wanted her, Ananya must break free from generations of expectations, even if it means returning every memory Kabir ever gave her.
Rejected by Him, Banished by My Family
Rejected by Him, Banished by My Family
4.9
For years, Megha chased Arjun Malhotra, only to be cast aside, sent abroad, and broken by cruel treatments meant to erase her love. Now back home, she’s forced to watch Arjun love her perfect sister—until one humiliating night shatters everything and her own family throws her out. But when a forbidden secret threatens to ruin her sister’s future, Megha must decide: will she stay silent and lose herself forever, or expose the truth that could destroy them all?
She Lied, I Spied: My Fiancée’s Secret Lover
She Lied, I Spied: My Fiancée’s Secret Lover
4.8
On the verge of marriage, I discovered my fiancée was leading a double life—sweet in my arms, but wild in another man's bed. Betrayed by the woman my family had already accepted, I became my own detective, uncovering every filthy secret she hid behind her innocent smile. Now, trapped between exposing her and protecting my shattered pride, I wonder: is revenge worth the heartbreak, or will I lose everything—including myself?
Traded for My Sister’s Happiness
Traded for My Sister’s Happiness
4.8
On the day her fiancé chose her younger sister over her, Priya’s world shattered—her dignity drowned before a crowd, and her family’s pride was sacrificed to preserve another’s virtue. Cast aside and humiliated, she must swap bridal cars, watching her childhood love cradle her rival while whispers poison her name. But when the wedding secret explodes and her sacrifice is exposed, will Priya reclaim her honour—or be forced to watch her sister take everything she was promised?
Seduced by My Enemy’s Betrayal
Seduced by My Enemy’s Betrayal
4.8
Meera, the orphaned topper, sacrifices everything for Kabir—the rich boy who fakes cancer and shatters her dignity in a viral group chat. Betrayed by her mother and hunted by her jealous stepsister Priya, Meera must choose: expose Kabir’s cruel game, or play along and destroy everyone who tried to ruin her. But when every secret is a weapon, who will fall first—her heart or her enemies?
He Made Me the Campus Villain
He Made Me the Campus Villain
4.8
Ananya thought the worst pain was public humiliation—until she learns her own boyfriend, Rohan, masterminded the cruel campus post that destroyed her. Betrayed, shamed, and forced to choose between her dreams and his demands, Ananya must fight for her identity when love turns into her greatest enemy. The truth cuts deeper than any insult: the man she trusted most was her secret tormentor all along.
Dumped Online, Chosen by My Best Friend’s Brother
Dumped Online, Chosen by My Best Friend’s Brother
4.7
When my online boyfriend ghosts me after mistaking my cats for secret kids, I’m shattered—divorced, alone, and judged without mercy. But just as my heart breaks, my best friend’s handsome, younger brother confesses he’s been searching for ways to win me—and my 'child'—over. Torn between virtual betrayal and a real-life second chance, will I risk everything for love that’s closer than I ever imagined?
My Ex-Husband’s Rival Wants Me Back
My Ex-Husband’s Rival Wants Me Back
4.8
After Bollywood superstar Arjun dumps Meera for his glamorous co-star, she’s forced to play the heartbroken wife on a national divorce reality show. But when she’s paired with Kabir—the mysterious actor everyone thought she’d left behind—the truth about her first love threatens to shatter Arjun’s carefully crafted image. With the whole country watching, old secrets ignite and Meera must choose: stay Arjun’s public shadow, or risk everything for the man she truly can’t forget.
Reborn as the Villain’s Scapegoat Bride
Reborn as the Villain’s Scapegoat Bride
4.9
On farewell night, I was framed and shamed as the campus villainess, forced into a loveless marriage with my childhood friend who only had eyes for the college queen. Betrayed, unloved, and killed in a tragic accident, I wake up back in my final year—armed with memories of every heartbreak and secret. This time, I’ll rewrite my fate, expose the real schemer, and rescue the bad boy who always called my name, even if it means tearing my own heart apart.