The Killer’s Confession Was a Lie / Chapter 7: The Last Confession
The Killer’s Confession Was a Lie

The Killer’s Confession Was a Lie

Author: Brett Donaldson


Chapter 7: The Last Confession

When I visited Caleb again, he looked even worse—hollowed out, eyes sunken.

Caleb’s hands balled into fists so tight his knuckles went pale, jaw clenched like he was biting back a scream.

But at this point, it didn’t matter if he accepted it or not.

His only hope was forgiveness from Mark’s family.

I was about to speak, but Caleb beat me to it:

“It’s not that there’s no evidence.”

His voice was so quiet, I almost missed it.

“What did you say?”

He looked up, face set:

“I have evidence.”

I flipped open my notebook, ready to write.

“What evidence?”

Caleb glanced at the door, then scribbled something down:

“This is my cloud drive and password. After you leave, log in. There’s one video in there—that’s the evidence.”

File: Evidence

“What’s in the video?”

“It’s Mark’s last words.”

I wanted to press for details, but Caleb just shook his head, repeating:

“Man, after you see it, I won’t have the face to see you again.”

I didn’t get it—how could there be last words? Caleb hanged Mark while he slept.

Puzzled, I rushed home, double-locked my apartment door that night, every car backfiring on the street making me flinch.

I logged into the cloud drive. The video was titled:

“Tom Reynolds’ Secret”

Was this what Mark used to blackmail Tom? Did Caleb force it out of him before killing him?

If so, things would get even uglier.

A chill crept up my spine.

I opened the video, hands trembling. If I turned this in, I’d be signing my own death warrant.

But it wasn’t what I expected.

Mark sat in front of the camera, fiddling with the angle. Room 201 behind him.

Caleb came in, sat down. He set his phone in front of the camera—call log open. The first call was to 911 at 3:00 p.m. on August 10. The clock read 3:03 p.m.

So this was after the call.

The video played:

Caleb: “I just called the police. It’s not too late to back out.”

Mark shook his head, smiling through his Ohio accent:

“I know Tom Reynolds’ secret, so when Caleb told me Tom wanted me dead, I wasn’t surprised. I have cancer. Treatment costs too much. My kid’s only nine. If I get treatment, I’ll drag them down.”

Mark started to cry, voice breaking:

“I’m not getting treated. I want to leave some money for my wife and kid, so I made a deal with Caleb. I let him kill me, and after he gets the money, he’ll give $90,000 to my wife.”

He turned to the camera:

“Honey, don’t blame me. I have cancer. I can’t drag you down. If you get the money, take our kid and start over. Kid, brush your teeth, don’t slack off in school. Take care of your health. I don’t know if you’ll ever see this.”

The video was blurry, but Mark’s pain was clear.

Caleb reminded him:

“Not much time left.”

Mark wiped his tears, looked into the camera:

“Tom Reynolds, it’s not that I couldn’t blackmail you for money. I just want my family to have something after I’m gone. But you promised Caleb the money. You want my life—I’ll give it.”

He added:

“I’ve already told Caleb your secret. If you stiff him, he’ll spill it. Don’t push honest people too far. This secret could cost you your life.”

He hit stop. The video lasted just over two minutes.

It was an arranged killing.

This chapter is VIP-only. Activate membership to continue.

You may also like

Confessions Before the Needle: The Killer's Truth
Confessions Before the Needle: The Killer's Truth
4.6
With just two hours left before his execution, Brian Ellis offers his counselor a chilling bargain: listen to the story that made him a monster. As secrets unravel—of a mother's desperate love, abuse that festered in silence, and a murder planned for years—Dr. Carter must decide if justice is ever as simple as it seems. But Brian’s final confession hides a twist that could haunt them both forever.
The Town That Died for My Lies
The Town That Died for My Lies
4.8
Emily was the pride of her dying Midwest town—until she slaughtered everyone who ever loved her. Now, shackled and smeared in shame, she stuns the nation with one final confession: her 'little brother' was never her brother at all, but the secret son she hid from everyone. As her true motives unravel under the glare of Deputy Chief Reed, the world must ask—how far will guilt, desperation, and a monstrous lie drive a girl who once carried all their hopes?
Only One Killer Gets Out Alive
Only One Killer Gets Out Alive
4.8
Fifteen years after Rachel's 'suicide,' a mysterious blackmailer resurfaces, threatening to expose Caleb and Jason's darkest secret: they pushed her off the roof to save themselves. Now, with their lives and families on the line, Caleb must decide—betray his only friend, or become a killer again to keep the truth buried. In this small-town Midwest nightmare, only one of them will survive the final reckoning.
She Framed Me to Save Her Lover
She Framed Me to Save Her Lover
4.8
Ryan died a villain in the world’s eyes, betrayed by the girl he sacrificed everything for. Now reborn to the day it all began, he refuses to play the hero—only to be falsely accused again when Emily, desperate to protect her secret love, names him as her attacker. This time, Ryan will expose every lie and reclaim his stolen life, no matter who he has to destroy.
Locked In With My Classmate’s Killer
Locked In With My Classmate’s Killer
4.7
Trapped in a condemned school, 49 classmates are forced into a deadly game: confess who drove Lillian Carter to her death, or die in a hail of poison and betrayal. Every choice splits old friendships and exposes buried guilt, as their class president-turned-tormentor unleashes twisted revenge. Only the truth can save them—but some secrets are worth killing for.
Stranger Kills for Hire: The Murder Exchange
Stranger Kills for Hire: The Murder Exchange
4.7
Detective Mike Lawson thought he'd seen every kind of cruelty—until a suburban family is butchered with surgical precision, their bodies scattered like trash. The killer confesses but claims no motive, leaving Mike haunted by the chilling truth: in Chicago, if you want to get away with murder, you don't kill your own enemy—you trade. As the city sleeps, a deadly pact is forged, and no one is safe from the next exchange.
He Chose Me to Defend His Crime
He Chose Me to Defend His Crime
4.6
Amy Bennett, a rookie lawyer with zero criminal experience, is handpicked by a confessed killer to defend him in a brutal murder case. The evidence screams 'guilty'—but Derek Harris swears he’ll reveal a secret that could turn the entire case upside down. With her career and conscience on the line, Amy must decide if the truth is worth risking everything for a man everyone already hates.
The Killer Vanished, But Her Husband Knows
The Killer Vanished, But Her Husband Knows
4.6
Five years after the brutal murder that shattered Maple Heights, the prime suspect vanished without a trace—leaving only a blood-soaked bedroom, a broken family, and a trail of secret money. As the victim’s grieving husband clings to memories and the killer’s mother guards her son’s secret, the truth festers in the shadows. When the past resurfaces, everyone must confront the horrifying question: What if the real monster never left?
My Daughter Lied, An Innocent Man Died
My Daughter Lied, An Innocent Man Died
4.8
When five girls accuse the beloved neighborhood bus driver of molestation, one father’s world shatters. As evidence unravels and a mother’s suicide rocks the city, he discovers his own daughter started it all—with a single, devastating lie. Now, with an innocent man in prison and the truth threatening to destroy his family, he faces an impossible choice: expose the secret or protect his own blood.
The Serial Killer Left Her in My Motel
The Serial Killer Left Her in My Motel
4.8
When a desperate motel owner lets a masked stranger and his unconscious date rent a room, he thinks it’s just another night—until he realizes he’s harboring a notorious serial killer. With hidden cameras recording every move and a dead girl upstairs, he’s trapped between turning himself in or covering up the crime. But when the killer discovers his secret, one chilling message changes everything: 'You shouldn’t have interfered.'
He Walked Free After Killing Her
He Walked Free After Killing Her
4.6
When a privileged predator murders an innocent college girl, her grieving father begs for justice—but the system rewards silence and connections instead. Trapped between a corrupt mentor and his own conscience, Jimmy must choose: protect his future, or expose the truth behind the courtroom’s dirty deals. In a world where money erases guilt, how much is a life really worth?
The Evidence Walked In: My Father’s Crime
The Evidence Walked In: My Father’s Crime
4.7
On the eve of a death sentence, a desperate young woman bursts into my law office, claiming she is not a witness—but the evidence itself. Her father died in a fireworks explosion twenty years ago, branded a thief and a traitor, and the whole town buried the truth. Now, as the final verdict looms, her secret threatens to unravel everything—because if her story is real, the wrong man is about to die.