Traded My Wife for My First Love / Chapter 5: What I Gave Up
Traded My Wife for My First Love

Traded My Wife for My First Love

Author: Norma Fisher


Chapter 5: What I Gave Up

After getting back together with Aubrey, I kept asking myself:

If I loved her so much, why did I marry Natalie in the first place? Was I chasing what I couldn’t have?

Deep down, I knew Natalie wasn’t just a backup. She was steady, reliable. But for a while, I couldn’t admit it.

Standing in the HR office, the answer hit me.

Jamie from HR told me Natalie had already finished handing off her work and left a resignation letter—just waiting for my signature to make it official.

Jamie handed me the envelope, Natalie’s handwriting neat and careful. My name printed across the top.

It hit me: I married Natalie because she always knew what I needed—even before I did. At work, at home, she was always there to ease my worries without a word.

But this time, it felt like she was letting me off too easy—like she was tired of cleaning up my messes.

If she’d waited for me to fire her, I would’ve given her a severance—one month’s pay for every year she’d worked. She deserved more than just a clean break.

I did the math in my head, guilt gnawing at me. Still, I signed "Agreed" and tucked the letter away.

I rehearsed what I’d tell Aubrey—how I’d spin it so she’d believe Natalie was really gone.

Jamie looked worried, fiddling with a stack of resumes. "Mr. Carter, who’s going to take over Natalie’s job?"

I shrugged. "Post a job ad and find someone new."

Jamie hesitated, voice dropping. "If we hire externally, with Natalie’s experience, we can’t offer just $30,000 a month. People with her skills start at $200,000 a year now..."

"Wait, what?" I set the folder down, eyeing Jamie. Was she trying to pull something?

Maybe she was angling for a raise, or covering for Natalie. Maybe she was just loyal to her old boss.

Either way, there was no way I’d pay that kind of money. We’re not some Silicon Valley giant.

"Jamie, the most I’ll offer is $75,000 a year. If you can’t hire someone, you don’t need to come to work anymore."

My voice was cold, final. That’s how you run a company—no room for excuses.

I left without looking back. Being a boss means moving forward, no matter how many people you leave behind.

I’d read enough management books to know: you can’t get too close to employees. Orders come from the top. If they can’t handle it, fire them. The company always comes first.

Someone will always step up when the pressure’s on. That’s how I convinced myself the work would get done—because it had to. That’s what being a boss means.

This chapter is VIP-only. Activate membership to continue.

You may also like

My Wife Sold Herself for Love
My Wife Sold Herself for Love
4.7
Dave thought love could heal anything—until a hotel escort card revealed his wife’s secret double life. Betrayed by the woman he sacrificed everything for, he’s forced to watch her slip into the arms of his own coworker. Now, with his marriage and career in ruins, Dave must decide: walk away, or take revenge on everyone who shattered his world.
I Let My Wife Die for My Mistress
I Let My Wife Die for My Mistress
4.8
The night my wife needed me most, I chose my first love instead—and my son will never forgive me. Now, haunted by guilt and shattered trust, I must rebuild a broken family with the woman who tore us apart. But when my son’s rage turns icy and unforgiving, can love ever wash away the blood on my hands?
Traded Her Life for My Promise
Traded Her Life for My Promise
4.8
At my engagement party, my world shatters when my best friend exposes the truth: the wife I thought dead has been waiting, betrayed and broken, for a decade. Her family has stolen everything from her—her money, her freedom, even her hope—forcing her into a coffin wedding to erase my memory. I’ll risk everything, even parachuting from a jet, to save the woman I abandoned and claim the love I swore to protect, even if it means turning my powerful fiancée into my enemy.
Traded for His First Love
Traded for His First Love
4.9
Natalie Carter thought she’d found safety in her marriage to the governor’s son—until his memories and his first love returned to shatter her world. Torn between pride and heartbreak, Natalie must decide if she’ll let Maple Heights define her worth, or if she’ll fight for a love that was never truly hers. In a town where reputations last forever, one wrong move could cost her everything.
My Wife Met My Mistress
My Wife Met My Mistress
5.0
Derek thought he’d buried his past—until a chance encounter with his ex ignites a wildfire of old passion and betrayal. Torn between a loyal wife and the woman who once shattered him, Derek risks everything for a taste of forbidden love. Now, one mistake threatens to blow up the perfect life he’s built, and someone’s about to get burned.
Traded for His Freedom, Never His Heart
Traded for His Freedom, Never His Heart
4.7
To save his disgraced family, Caleb Lin marries me—a nobody with nothing but callused hands and a borrowed name. For three years, I played the loyal wife while he pined for his childhood sweetheart, Grace. Now that his father's name is cleared, all that's left is a divorce agreement and a heart that never truly belonged to me.
Cheating on My Wife With a Stranger
Cheating on My Wife With a Stranger
4.7
One wild night on a mountaintop with a captivating stranger shatters my ten-year marriage and turns my life into a storm of guilt, lust, and betrayal. My wife is perfect but always gone; Natalie is wild, reckless, and impossible to forget. When my secret explodes in the most humiliating way, I’m forced to choose between the love I built and the passion I can’t let go.
He Traded Me for His Childhood Love
He Traded Me for His Childhood Love
4.8
After seven years of sacrifice, Shannon’s world shatters when her politician husband replaces her with his ex—her children cheering him on. Betrayed by the family she built, she’s forced to fight for her dignity, her inheritance, and her mother’s legacy. When the divorce is announced on her own front porch, will she walk away broken—or rise to claim the freedom and revenge she deserves?
My Wife Waited While I Betrayed Her
My Wife Waited While I Betrayed Her
4.8
I was the husband everyone envied—until my secret affair with the girl I once worshipped shattered everything. While my wife braved the snow for my health and waited up with a birthday feast, I was tangled in another woman's arms, convincing myself guilt was love. Now, in the freezing silence, my wife stares through the glass, and I know the truth is about to destroy the only warmth I have left.
His Wife, Not His Choice
His Wife, Not His Choice
4.7
For ten years, Annie was traded from one cold home to another, finally forced into a loveless marriage with Jason Carter—the wealthy heir who never wanted her. She gave him loyalty, care, and her body, but he saved his love for another woman and called Annie dirty in her own house. When she finally asks for a divorce, Jason refuses—not out of love, but because he can't bear to lose his caretaker, leaving Annie to choose: stay invisible, or walk away and reclaim her life.
She Sold Our Love for a Condo
She Sold Our Love for a Condo
4.7
Five years of love—gone the moment my fiancée tasted money. Her family’s run-down trailer became a golden ticket, and suddenly I was just another bidder for her heart. When she demanded $150,000 or five condos to marry her, I realized: I was nothing but a price tag, and the girl I loved was already gone.
I Betrayed My Pregnant Wife for Her
I Betrayed My Pregnant Wife for Her
4.7
While my wife carried our unborn child, I gave in to a forbidden affair with my ambitious subordinate. Torn between the security of my marriage and the thrill of Madison’s reckless passion, I risked everything—my job, my family, my soul—for a woman who might never love me back. But when my wife went into labor, Madison forced me to choose: would I watch my daughter be born, or run into the arms of my mistress?