Trapped With My Best Friend’s Ex / Chapter 7: The Game Never Ends
Trapped With My Best Friend’s Ex

Trapped With My Best Friend’s Ex

Author: Margaret Henderson


Chapter 7: The Game Never Ends

People often post online, "If you suddenly had thirty million, how would you live?"

There were Reddit threads, Instagram reels, and late-night debates at dive bars. Derek and I were living the answer, the American dream—if your dream included a heavy dose of survivor’s guilt.

Derek and I are living examples. Save half, splurge half. We moved into a big house in the suburbs and drove a Porsche. We’d often invite models over for pool parties.

We bought a Craftsman-style home in a leafy neighborhood outside Austin, filled the fridge with craft beer, and hosted Fourth of July parties that neighbors gossiped about for months. I learned to grill steaks, Derek tried (and failed) to keep the pool clean.

But there’s one thing Derek wouldn’t touch: music. He packed up all the albums of his favorite singers from before we transmigrated and put them in the basement. When he closed the door, he asked me, "Got anything to throw away?"

He stood in the cool, shadowy basement, his hands lingering on a stack of old vinyls. There was a finality in the way he taped up the box, like burying the last piece of who he used to be.

I said, "Already did."

I shrugged, keeping it casual. Old habits die hard.

"What?"

He looked at me, eyebrow raised, expecting a punchline.

"Five Years of SAT Prep, Three Years of Practice Tests (Physics Edition), Starting from Zero to Learn Olympiad Math—I tossed them after the SATs."

I let the words hang there, hoping he’d get the joke. But I could see the nostalgia flicker in his eyes.

Derek rolled his eyes and sat by the pool. The evening breeze was gentle. The distant sound of girls splashing in the pool never felt so real and alive.

The sun dipped low, casting everything in gold. The laughter, the sizzle of the grill, the smell of sunscreen—life finally felt tangible again. But sometimes, late at night, I caught Derek staring at nothing, lost in old ghosts.

Even after a whole year, those people and things still surfaced in our minds unexpectedly. But Derek and I never mentioned it.

The past was a scar that itched, but we agreed—no looking back. Not out loud, anyway.

Derek sipped his watermelon juice, tilted his head, and waved at a girl in the distance. "Actually, the system came to me later. It seemed to offer some therapy or something..."

He acted like it was no big deal, but his voice wavered just a touch. Therapy, closure—who really believes in that?

I turned to look at him, listening as he continued, "It kept saying those were just past dreams, like a murder mystery game—when the lights come on, it’s all over. But some things, I think only you understand. How could things we really experienced be fake? You know, now I want to puke whenever I see alcohol."

He said it like a joke, but I caught the pain behind the words. Sometimes, the system’s logic made sense—sometimes, it was just a Band-Aid over a bullet hole.

Derek said this with a smile. But I always felt he wasn’t truly happy. There was a scar on his heart. Maybe it would be torn open again at some unguarded moment, bleeding once more.

I watched him for a moment, wondering if any of us ever really heal. We survived, sure—but we didn’t win. Not in the ways that count.

Just like after I came back, I unconsciously held back. For example, Aubrey doesn’t like spicy food, so when the boss asks about flavor, I habitually say no to spicy. Derek and I weren’t winners of this game—just survivors.

It’s funny what sticks. Old preferences, old loyalties—they sneak up on you, reminders of a world you can’t go back to.

The live music grew louder, snapping me back to the present as the atmosphere quickly became lively again. Derek tossed down his glass. "I swear, tonight I’ll hit on every girl!"

He grinned, wild and reckless, his old bravado coming back for an encore.

I said, "Me too."

We exchanged a look—brothers-in-arms, ready for anything. The world felt bright and endless, if only for a moment.

The two of us jumped into the pool one after the other. The music was so loud that we didn’t hear the damn system reboot.

It was like an air raid siren in the middle of the party—no warning, just chaos.

It broke the sound system and shouted at the top of its lungs, panic in its voice:

"Detected main character’s death in the novel world. Target used abnormal means. Forcibly recalling hosts. Teleportation begins in three seconds."

Derek and I, arms around pretty girls, barely had time to react—

Everything froze. The water felt like syrup, the music warped and distant. Three seconds can be a lifetime when you know you’re about to lose everything again.

Then, everything went black. We lost consciousness.

The last thing I heard was Derek cursing under his breath. Then, nothing.

This chapter is VIP-only. Activate membership to continue.

You may also like

Trapped With Her Victim’s Corpse
Trapped With Her Victim’s Corpse
4.8
I broke into the wrong apartment, only to hide from the owner—while her last victim’s body dangled inches above me in the closet. Now I’m trapped, forced to watch her drug and butcher her next target, terrified I’ll be next. My only way out is past the killer who already claimed my best friend.
My Best Friend Made Me Break Up With My Duo
My Best Friend Made Me Break Up With My Duo
4.8
When my bestie and I duo queue with two top-ranked brothers to escape Diamond IV, the lines between friendship, love, and rivalry blur fast. Betrayal, petty breakups, and online drama explode into real life when our exes show up at the local rec center—and suddenly, my best friend’s loyalty is the only thing standing between me and a gamer-boy disaster. But when my ex threatens to deliver a 'birthday present' in person, I realize the game isn’t over—and this time, there’s no way to log off.
Her Best Friend Wants My Girl
Her Best Friend Wants My Girl
4.9
When Alex finds a box of condoms in his girlfriend’s clothes—ones he can’t even use—he realizes he’s losing her to her lifelong best friend. As old wounds and jealousies erupt, Alex is forced to fight for Natalie while the world (and her heart) roots for someone else. Will he step aside, or finally claim center stage in the drama of their love triangle?
Stolen by My Ex’s Best Friend
Stolen by My Ex’s Best Friend
5.0
Natalie thought her love for Derek would last forever, until his childhood best friend Hailey shattered everything. Now, caught between past betrayals and old flames, Natalie must decide if holding on will destroy her—or if letting go is the only way to save herself. Will she finally break free, or will the ghosts of first love pull her under?
My Best Friend’s Wife Moved In
My Best Friend’s Wife Moved In
4.6
When Marcus is arrested for embezzlement, his stunning new wife Rachel turns to me for help—and in one desperate night, ends up stranded in my apartment. I’m supposed to save their marriage, but every secret she shares and every stolen glance pushes us closer to a line we can’t uncross. If Marcus finds out what happened between us, it’ll destroy everything—but can I really let her go?
Quarantined Hearts: Stuck With My Ex
Quarantined Hearts: Stuck With My Ex
4.8
Ava Monroe just wanted closure with her ex—but a sudden quarantine traps her in his apartment with his maybe-girlfriend. Forced into close quarters, old wounds and new sparks ignite, leaving Ava torn between heartbreak and hope. As secrets unravel, she must decide if love is worth fighting for, even when the world is on pause.
Trapped With Her Ex’s Fiancée
Trapped With Her Ex’s Fiancée
4.6
Skylar was supposed to be the next naive target, but instead she flips the script—demanding a front-row seat to the twisted games that ruined her engagement. Now, surrounded by men who once preyed on women, she’s the only one who knows their secrets and refuses to play by their rules. When the tables turn and the hunters become the hunted, can anyone survive the wilderness—or Skylar’s revenge?
Betrayed by My Best Friend
Betrayed by My Best Friend
4.9
After a decade of scraping by and losing touch, one man is forced to confront the painful memories and fractured friendships of his college days when a surprise reunion text drags him back into a web of guilt, jealousy, and secrets. As old wounds resurface, he must face the truth about loyalty, failure, and the friend they all left behind. If he can’t make peace with the past, he risks losing himself—and the last of his brotherhood—forever.
Handcuffed by My Ex
Handcuffed by My Ex
5.0
Natalie thought her past with Derek Shaw was dead and buried—until her ex-husband’s crimes drag her back into the heart of danger, and her first love is the one putting her in cuffs. Torn between old wounds and new betrayals, she faces a web of obsession, revenge, and a love that refuses to die. Will she escape the shadows of her past, or be destroyed by them for good?
Abandoned by My Wife at Her Reunion
Abandoned by My Wife at Her Reunion
4.7
Logan’s desperate call for help is mocked when his wife, Shannon, refuses to leave her high school reunion—even as his mother suffers a heart attack. Trapped in a room full of her old friends and first love, Logan is humiliated and forced to prove his love in front of a jeering crowd. When faced with an impossible choice—save his mother or save his marriage—Logan realizes the woman he loves may already be lost to him.
I Dumped My Crush—His Roommate Craved Me
I Dumped My Crush—His Roommate Craved Me
4.9
I always thought being a succubus in college would make my love life easy—until my childhood friend ghosted me for the campus queen on Valentine’s Day. Now, with the universe streaming my every move like a reality show—complete with savage floating comments—I’m stuck between Mason’s mixed signals and his brooding roommate Caleb, who’s way more than just a background character. As old hookups lose their spark and new desires heat up, I’m forced to choose: chase what’s familiar, or risk everything on the guy who sees through my every act? When the comments demand drama and the past won’t let go, can I rewrite my own story—or will I just become the villain in someone else’s feed?
Trapped as the Fiancée He Wants to Ruin
Trapped as the Fiancée He Wants to Ruin
4.7
Rachel’s engagement is nothing but a family contract—her fiancé Derek wants her gone, but not before destroying her reputation. When his best friend Marcus is sent to seduce and expose her, Rachel turns the tables, playing the perfect lovesick fiancée while plotting her own revenge. But as betrayals mount and secrets spill, Rachel’s heartbreak becomes her sharpest weapon—and Derek might lose much more than his pride.