He Chose My Rival Over Me / Chapter 1: The Day Everything Changed
He Chose My Rival Over Me

He Chose My Rival Over Me

Author: Nicole Ward


Chapter 1: The Day Everything Changed

Next →

I was just about to reach into the box when, all of a sudden, glowing subtitles flickered right in front of my face:

[The broke main character doesn’t even know her parents left gold for her, buried right in the plot behind her house.]

[I heard that plot with the gold was secretly rigged by the main character’s fiancé to give to his true love.]

[That’s right, the guy folded that slip into a triangle so his true love would pick it. The main character is really getting the short end of the stick.]

I looked down, confused. My breath caught. Was I hallucinating? I blinked hard, but the glowing words just hovered there, taunting me.

There really was a slip of paper folded into a triangle in the wooden box.

As my fingers hovered over the box, the morning sun spilled in through the rec center’s windows, catching dust motes in the air. The room smelled faintly of old varnish and burnt coffee from the refreshments table. I glanced around, half-expecting someone to gasp or point, but nobody seemed to notice the floating words. Just the scrape of folding chairs and the low buzz of small-town gossip.

It felt like I was inside a TV show, with someone else’s running commentary popping up where only I could see.

1

[No spoilers please, I just started watching.]

[What’s she staring at? Why hasn’t she picked yet?]

What is going on?

While I stood there dazed, the other folks waiting in line to draw lots started to grumble:

"Hey, let’s keep it moving, folks—some of us gotta get back to work."

"Come on! The rest of us are still waiting."

The voices sounded impatient, someone even tapping their foot against the linoleum. Behind me, I caught the scent of leather work gloves and the sharp tang of motor oil—a sure sign that half the town’s farmers and mechanics were here for their slice of Maple Heights.

I didn’t have time to worry about whether the subtitles were real or not.

Flustered, I gritted my teeth and grabbed the triangular slip of paper.

My palm felt clammy as I pressed the sharp crease of the paper. My heart hammered so loud I was sure the whole room could hear. I tried to swallow, but my mouth was dry as sawdust. Suddenly aware of every eye in the room on me, the heat of embarrassment prickled up my neck.

Mr. Harlan, the town mayor, opened the slip and read out loud:

"Natalie Carson’s family, plot number 5."

My heart pounded like a drum.

Plot number 5—

It was the plot right behind my house,

The one the subtitles said had gold buried in it.

[What the heck?]

[How did she pick it? Did she suddenly wake up, like she knows what’s coming?]

[Hmm, is the second round of the story going to change too?]

I could practically hear the whispers bounce off the town hall walls, a hush falling over the room before the next name was called. My hands trembled as I clutched the slip, a weird sense of fate tightening around me, both terrifying and electric.

Next →

You may also like

He Chose Her Over Me
He Chose Her Over Me
5.0
Natalie always believed her childhood love with Derek would last forever—until a wild outsider named Aubrey crashes into their lives, stealing his affection and her family's loyalty. Betrayed and replaced, Natalie must fight for her place in a small town where secrets, jealousy, and heartbreak simmer beneath the surface. She’s about to prove she’s nobody’s backup plan.
He Chose My Sister Over Me
He Chose My Sister Over Me
5.0
Jenna spent high school invisible, mocked for her weight and crushed when her secret crush chose her perfect sister. Eight years later, Jenna returns to her hometown—transformed and married—only to confront old betrayals, family jealousy, and the man who once broke her heart. But revenge tastes sweeter when the tables turn and a new love steps out of the shadows.
He Chose Her—So I Chose Me
He Chose Her—So I Chose Me
4.9
A car ride was all it took to shatter twenty years of sacrifice. When I, a devoted single mother, dared to sit beside my son, his girlfriend unleashed accusations that turned my world upside down—and my own child sided with her. I’d saved, planned, and dreamed for his future, only to be cast out and humiliated. As family lines blur and loyalty is tested, I’m forced to make a choice: cling to the son who betrayed me, or finally put myself first. Will my heartbreak become my freedom, or will the past pull me back in? When love turns to war, who gets the front seat in your life?
He Chose His Mistress Over Me
He Chose His Mistress Over Me
4.8
Rachel lost her family and clung to Ethan, the only man who ever showed her kindness—until the day he declared his secret lover would become his second wife. Humiliated and cast aside, Rachel is forced to plan their wedding, all while the whole town watches her heartbreak. But with the annulment papers signed, she realizes she doesn’t need anyone’s pity—least of all Ethan’s—and vows to reclaim her life, no matter how many rumors or rivals stand in her way.
Stolen by My Boyfriend’s Secret Admirer
Stolen by My Boyfriend’s Secret Admirer
4.8
When I defend a classmate from public humiliation, she turns her gratitude toward my boyfriend—and then invades every corner of our lives. Betrayed and blindsided, I fight to keep my love and dignity as a cunning rival spins a web of lies and sabotage. With my relationship and reputation at stake, I must decide: stand my ground or lose everything to the girl I tried to save.
I Married My Rival Next Door
I Married My Rival Next Door
4.9
Our feud was legendary, our wedding a disaster—so why can’t I stop falling for the one man I was born to hate? Forced to marry the son of my dad’s sworn enemy, I thought I’d spend my days dodging Colton’s threats and my nights plotting my escape. Instead, I’m tangled in his arms, outwitted by his stubborn charm, and haunted by memories of our childhood battles. With the whole town watching, eighteen romance guides in my suitcase, and my family’s pride on the line, every move feels like a test. But when old grudges spark new desire, and his touch feels more like home than hate, I have to wonder: Are we doomed to destroy each other—or could loving my enemy be the bravest thing I’ve ever done? What happens when the war of hearts becomes a fight neither of us wants to win?
The Main Guy Chose the Wrong Girl
The Main Guy Chose the Wrong Girl
4.7
Rachel always played the part of the cold, perfect student—never the main character, always the villain in someone else’s story. But when the new transfer heartthrob declares he came for her, the entire school—and her so-called childhood friend—turn on her, hungry for drama. Now she’s caught in a viral love triangle, hated by the heroine, hunted by jealous rivals, and forced to choose: play the villain, or finally take the lead.
I Dumped My Crush—His Roommate Craved Me
I Dumped My Crush—His Roommate Craved Me
4.9
I always thought being a succubus in college would make my love life easy—until my childhood friend ghosted me for the campus queen on Valentine’s Day. Now, with the universe streaming my every move like a reality show—complete with savage floating comments—I’m stuck between Mason’s mixed signals and his brooding roommate Caleb, who’s way more than just a background character. As old hookups lose their spark and new desires heat up, I’m forced to choose: chase what’s familiar, or risk everything on the guy who sees through my every act? When the comments demand drama and the past won’t let go, can I rewrite my own story—or will I just become the villain in someone else’s feed?
He Was Meant for Her—But Chose Me
He Was Meant for Her—But Chose Me
5.0
He was supposed to fall for someone else. I was supposed to be the villain—until fate, a stubborn transmigrator, and a broken story system rewrote our lines. When I deliver a love letter for the third time to Carter Hayes, the boy I grew up with (and maybe secretly loved), I spark a confession that upends everything: Carter likes me, not the 'main girl.' But our world isn’t real—it's a story fighting to snap back into place, and every choice risks erasing us for good. As mysterious tasks, forbidden kisses, and heart-stopping resets threaten to tear us apart, I have to ask: Can love survive when the universe demands we play our roles? Or will the villain finally get her happily ever after—no matter what the script says?
He Chose His Assistant Over Me
He Chose His Assistant Over Me
4.8
When my husband Marcus betrayed me with his bright-eyed assistant, my heartbreak went viral—turning my plea for a new husband into a national sensation. As the world watched, I spiraled through illness, betrayal, and the agony of being replaced by the very woman I once pitied. Now, with nothing left to lose, I’m ready to reclaim my light—even if it means burning down the life we built together.
I Chose Myself, They Chose Her
I Chose Myself, They Chose Her
4.9
Betrayal tastes bitter when it’s family. When Casey learns she’s the only one who can save her sister’s life, she tests her family’s love with a single devastating lie. But in her parents’ home, loyalty is a one-way street—and Casey is about to be cast out for good. Surrounded by indifference and favoritism, she faces a choice between saving herself or sacrificing everything for those who never chose her. As secrets unravel and accusations fly, Casey must decide: will she cling to the hope of belonging, or finally walk away to protect the new life growing inside her? When blood is just another weapon, can she survive the cut?
He Chose Her Over Me—Again
He Chose Her Over Me—Again
4.7
Emily always thought she’d be the Howell bride, until Chris shattered her trust—sacrificing her happiness for his mentor’s orphaned daughter. Humiliated, overlooked, and expected to give up everything for Lily, Emily finally refuses to play the gracious loser. When Chris announces his own engagement to Lily out of duty, Emily must decide: will she keep living in someone else’s shadow, or claim her own future—even if it means breaking every rule of Chicago high society?